Electric Charges and Fields · Lesson 3 of 11
Superposition of Electric Forces
“Combine pairwise forces using components and symmetry, without confusing scalar charge sums with vector force sums.”
• Apply the superposition principle to fixed point-charge configurations. • Resolve forces into components in a common coordinate system. • Use symmetry to justify cancellation and identify when it fails. • Find a zero-force location and distinguish equilibrium from stability.
A new physical principle, not just vector arithmetic
Place a third charge near a pair. For fixed source positions, the force contributed by either source is the same pairwise Coulomb force as before. The total force on the selected charge is the vector sum of these contributions. This is the empirical superposition principle. Vector addition tells us how to combine the forces once this physical independence has been established; it does not establish the independence itself. If charges on a conductor rearrange when another object approaches, the source configuration has changed and must first be found again.
Build a diagram before adding
First select the body whose force is required. Draw one arrow at that body for each other charge: away from a same-sign source and toward an opposite-sign source. Label the separation for each pair, since they need not be equal. Choose perpendicular axes and resolve each arrow, preserving signs. Add all x components and all y components separately. Only then find the magnitude and direction of the resultant. Adding positive magnitudes is valid only when every contribution points in the same direction.
Problem
A +1.0 μC test charge is at the origin. A +2.0 μC source is at (0.30 m, 0), and a −3.0 μC source at (0, 0.30 m). Find the net force on the test charge.
- 1.The positive source repels the test charge along −x: Fₓ = −(9 × 10⁹)(2 × 10⁻¹²)/0.09 = −0.20 N.
- 2.The negative source attracts it along +y: Fᵧ = +(9 × 10⁹)(3 × 10⁻¹²)/0.09 = +0.30 N.
- 3.The magnitude is √(0.20² + 0.30²) = 0.361 N. It points 56.3° above −x, or 123.7° counterclockwise from +x. Adding magnitudes would incorrectly give 0.50 N.
Symmetry is a reason, not a guess
Three equal charges at the vertices of an equilateral triangle produce equal force magnitudes on a charge at the centroid. Their directions are 120° apart; their components sum to zero. A rotation by 120° leaves the source configuration unchanged, so a nonzero in-plane resultant would wrongly select a preferred direction. A 60° rotation does not leave a three-vertex configuration unchanged. State the actual symmetry rather than using any convenient angle.
Problem
A square has equal charges +q at opposite vertices A and C and equal charges −Q at opposite vertices B and D. Find the force on any test charge at its centre.
- 1.Distances from opposite vertices to the centre are equal. The fields due to A and C point oppositely with equal magnitudes, so cancel. The B and D pair also cancel separately.
- 2.The net field and hence the test-charge force are zero even when q and Q differ. This conclusion uses opposing pairs, not zero total source charge.
Problem
Place +q at A = (−l/2, 0), +q at B = (l/2, 0) and −q at C = (0, √3l/2). Find the forces on all three in terms of F₀ = kq²/l².
- 1.At A, repulsion from B is (−F₀, 0). Attraction toward C is (F₀/2, √3F₀/2). Net F_A = (−F₀/2, √3F₀/2), magnitude F₀.
- 2.At B, the net is (F₀/2, √3F₀/2), also magnitude F₀. At C, the two attractions sum to (0, −√3F₀), magnitude √3F₀.
- 3.The three net-force vectors sum to zero because all internal pair forces cancel. This does not mean any individual charge has zero force.
Finding and interpreting a zero-force position
Problem
Two fixed charges +q and +4q are at x = 0 and x = L. Find where a nonzero test charge has zero electric force.
- 1.Outside the interval the source fields point in the same direction, so cannot cancel. Between the charges they oppose.
- 2.Let the point be x from +q: kq/x² = k(4q)/(L−x)². Positive distances give L−x = 2x, hence x = L/3.
- 3.The point is closer to the weaker source. Zero force for a test charge follows from zero net field, regardless of the test charge sign. It does not prove stable equilibrium in all directions.
A small displacement may change the force direction differently along different axes. For two like sources a positive test charge can be restored along the joining line but pushed farther away after a transverse displacement. Do not label a cancellation point “stable” without investigating allowed displacements. Superposition problems usually assume sources are held fixed; if they are released, calculate their individual equations of motion rather than assuming the entire geometry persists.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
Two equal perpendicular forces each have magnitude F. Their resultant magnitude is
Explanation: The sum of component squares is 2F².
Zero total source charge guarantees zero field at every point. This statement is
Explanation: An equal-and-opposite pair generally has a nonzero dipole field.
Three equal vectors separated by 120° sum to
Explanation: Their two Cartesian component sums both vanish.
Superposition assumes each pairwise contribution for fixed sources is
Explanation: This physical independence is distinct from the vector-addition rule.
The zero-field point between +q and +4q lies
Explanation: The weaker source needs a shorter distance to match the stronger field.
Practice Problems
- Sources exert forces (3, 4) N and (−5, 2) N on a charge. Find its net force and magnitude.
- At the centre of a 0.10 m square, opposite vertex pairs carry +2 μC,+2 μC and −5 μC,−5 μC. Find the force on +1 μC there and explain why.
- For +q at 0 and +9q at L on the x-axis, find the zero-field point.
- For +q at x = 0 and −4q at x = L, locate the zero-field point.
- Three equal fixed positive charges occupy an equilateral triangle. Explain zero force at its centroid and what changes if one charge is removed.
Add components: F = (−2, 6) N. Magnitude = √40 = 6.32 N. The vector is in quadrant II, at about 108.4° from +x. It is neither the sum nor difference of the individual magnitudes.
Key Takeaways
• Superposition adds pairwise forces for fixed source configurations. • Charge sums are scalar; force sums are vector. • Draw each force on the selected charge before resolving components. • Symmetry requires matching both geometry and charge values. • Internal forces sum to zero for an isolated electrostatic charge collection. • A zero-force point need not be stable in every direction.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…