Electric Charges and Fields · Lesson 7 of 11
Dipoles in External Fields
“Explain how a neutral dipole can rotate in a uniform field and experience net force in a suitable nonuniform field.”
• Derive the torque on a rigid permanent dipole in a uniform external field. • Determine torque direction using the ordered cross product p × E. • Distinguish zero net force from zero torque and compare equilibrium orientations. • Explain neutral-object attraction using induced dipoles and field nonuniformity.
Two equal forces can turn an object
Consider a rigid permanent dipole in an external electric field, excluding the field produced by its own charges. If that external field is uniform, +q feels +qE and −q feels −qE. The two forces cancel as vectors, so the dipole’s centre of mass has no electric translational acceleration. They act at different points, however, so they can produce a couple. Equal and opposite forces do not generally imply zero torque.
Let the full separation be d = 2a and let θ be the angle between p and E. The perpendicular distance between the two parallel force lines is d sinθ. Multiplying either force magnitude qE by that distance gives the couple torque qEd sinθ = pE sinθ. Alternatively, calculate both torques about the midpoint; each lever arm has length a and each contributes aqE sinθ in the same rotational sense.
Cross-product direction and equilibrium
Place your right-hand fingers along p and curl toward E through the smaller angle; your thumb gives torque direction perpendicular to their plane. For p tilted upward to the right while E points right, p × E points into the page, giving clockwise rotation. Reversing the cross-product order gives the wrong sign. Torque vanishes at θ = 0° and 180°, but these orientations differ in stability. A small angular displacement from parallel alignment creates a restoring torque; a small displacement from antiparallel alignment drives the dipole farther away. Parallel is stable rotational equilibrium, antiparallel unstable. Maximum torque magnitude occurs at 90°.
A restoring torque does not mean the dipole instantly stops aligned. With negligible damping it can overshoot and oscillate; dissipation is needed for settling. The uniform field does no net translational work on the rigid dipole centre, yet it can change rotational motion. The dimensions of torque are N m, but torque is a vector turning effect, not simply interchangeable with scalar work or energy.
Problem
A dipole has p = 4.0 × 10⁻⁹ C m and lies 30° counterclockwise from a rightward field E = 5.0 × 10⁴ N C⁻¹. Find the torque.
- 1.Magnitude τ = pE sin30° = (4.0 × 10⁻⁹)(5.0 × 10⁴)(0.5) = 1.0 × 10⁻⁴ N m.
- 2.With x right and y up, p has a positive y component and E has only positive x component, so τ_z = −p_yE_x. The torque is into the page, clockwise.
- 3.The net electric force remains zero because the external field has the same vector at both charges.
What changes in a nonuniform field?
If the external field differs at the two charge locations, the forces need not cancel. The exact net force is q[E(r₊) − E(r₋)] for this pair. For a short dipole lying along a straight field whose magnitude varies slowly along that direction, a parallel dipole is pulled toward stronger field: its forward positive charge is pushed more strongly than its rear negative charge is pulled back. Reversing the dipole reverses that comparison. This one-dimensional example does not mean every nonuniform field produces a nonzero force for every orientation; geometry can make the two sampled vectors equal.
Problem
A dipole with q = 2.0 nC and separation 1.0 mm is aligned along +x. The external field points +x and has magnitude 1000 N C⁻¹ at −q and 1100 N C⁻¹ at +q. Find the net force.
- 1.Force on +q is +2.2 × 10⁻⁶ N; force on −q is −2.0 × 10⁻⁶ N. Their sum is +2.0 × 10⁻⁷ N.
- 2.Both force lines lie on the dipole axis, so torque about the midpoint is zero. The dipole translates toward the stronger field without an initial turning effect.
- 3.The approximate gradient is 100/(10⁻³) = 10⁵ N C⁻¹ m⁻¹; p = 2 × 10⁻¹² C m gives the same F = p dE/dx.
Why a charged comb attracts neutral paper
An electric field shifts positive and negative charge centres in paper slightly apart. The induced moment tends to point along the local field. Near a charged comb the field is stronger on the nearer side, so attraction of the nearer opposite charge can exceed repulsion of the farther like charge. The paper can move toward the comb while remaining neutral overall. The effect involves both polarisation and nonuniformity. In an ideal uniform field an ideal induced pair with equal opposite charges has no net translational force, even though internal charge separation occurs.
Double E while holding a permanent p and θ fixed: torque doubles. Double the uniform field and ask whether centre-of-mass force doubles: it stays zero. For an induced dipole, p itself may depend on E, so a fixed-p scaling rule cannot be assumed.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
An ideal rigid dipole in a uniform external E generally has
Explanation: The two forces cancel, but their separated lines of action can form a couple.
Torque direction is given by
Explanation: The ordered cross product specifies rotation.
The stable rotational orientation of a permanent dipole is
Explanation: A small angular disturbance from parallel alignment produces restoring torque.
Maximum torque magnitude for fixed p and E occurs at
Explanation: The sine factor has its maximum value one.
Neutral paper can be attracted to a comb because
Explanation: Charge separation plus a field gradient permits net attraction.
Practice Problems
- Find torque for p = 3.0 × 10⁻⁸ C m in E = 2.0 × 10³ N C⁻¹ at 60°.
- Derive τ = pE sinθ from the two end forces and distinguish it from net force.
- Explain why both parallel and antiparallel configurations have zero torque but different stability.
- A +1 nC end feels 5 × 10⁻⁶ N to the right and its −1 nC partner feels 3 × 10⁻⁶ N to the left. Find net force and explain the field.
- Does a permanent dipole released at 30° in a uniform field necessarily come to rest at 0°?
Use τ = pE sinθ = 6.0 × 10⁻⁵ × 0.866 = 5.20 × 10⁻⁵ N m. The vector direction is perpendicular to p and E according to p × E. Magnitude alone cannot specify into or out of a page without a stated geometry.
Key Takeaways
• A uniform external field produces equal opposite forces on dipole ends. • Zero net force can coexist with a nonzero torque. • The torque is p × E with magnitude pE sinθ. • Parallel alignment is stable rotational equilibrium; antiparallel is unstable. • A nonuniform field can produce a net dipole force. • Polarisation and unequal end forces explain attraction of neutral paper.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…