Electric Charges and Fields · Lesson 10 of 11
Fields from Symmetric Charge Distributions
“Derive the fields of a long wire, infinite plane sheet and spherical shell by matching source symmetry to a Gaussian surface.”
• Choose Gaussian surfaces justified by cylindrical, planar or spherical source symmetry. • Derive fields for an infinite line, an infinite sheet and a uniform thin spherical shell. • State finite-source limitations and distinguish an insulating sheet from a conductor surface. • Interpret field graphs and solve an enclosed-charge model with spherical symmetry.
Symmetry does the work before Gauss’s law
A Gaussian surface is useful when source symmetry tells us both the field direction and where its magnitude is constant. The surface is imaginary and contributes no charge of its own. In each derivation below, the field is due to the entire physical source even though Gauss’s law uses only the charge inside the chosen boundary. Adding an asymmetric external charge leaves Gauss’s law valid but can destroy the simple field-evaluation shortcut.
An infinitely long uniformly charged thin wire
Take the wire along z with signed linear density λ. Translating along an infinite wire or rotating around it changes nothing about the source. Reflection pairing of elements above and below an observation point cancels axial components; reflection in planes through the wire rules out azimuthal components. The field is radial, and its signed radial component depends only on perpendicular distance r. Choose a coaxial closed cylinder of radius r and length L. On its curved wall E is normal and constant in magnitude. On the two flat ends it is tangent, so their fluxes vanish.
The cylinder length cancels because extending it adds equal proportions of flux-carrying wall area and enclosed charge. The field falls as 1/r: doubling r halves it. An actual finite wire approaches this result near its middle when distance from the wire is small compared with distances to its ends. Near the ends the axial cancellation and translation symmetry fail. The line model is singular at r = 0 and does not describe a real wire’s interior.
Problem
An ideal infinite line produces |E| = 9.0 × 10⁴ N C⁻¹ at r = 0.020 m. Find |λ|.
- 1.Rearrange: |λ| = 2πε₀r|E| = 2π × 8.854 × 10⁻¹² × 0.020 × 9.0 × 10⁴ ≈ 1.00 × 10⁻⁷ C m⁻¹.
- 2.The magnitude alone does not give the sign. Outward E would mean positive λ; inward E negative λ.
A uniformly charged infinite plane sheet
Translational symmetry within the sheet makes the field independent of the in-plane coordinates. Reflection symmetry makes its direction perpendicular to the sheet, and the magnitudes on opposite sides equal. Choose a short closed pillbox crossing the sheet, with flat faces of area A parallel to it. Field is tangent to the side wall, producing zero side flux. It is along each outward normal for positive σ, so the two face fluxes add rather than cancel.
Distance independence does not imply a finite plate produces a constant field to infinity. The infinite sheet has no lateral edge or finite total charge. A large finite sheet approximates this field near its middle at distances small compared with its lateral dimensions; far away it resembles a finite total charge and edge effects matter. Do not confuse σ/(2ε₀), the field of a symmetric sheet, with σ_face/ε₀ just outside a conductor whose interior E is zero. The conductor result follows from one nonzero pillbox face and the total local surface charge condition, a different geometry.
Problem
Parallel sheets carry +σ and −σ, with σ = 17.0 × 10⁻²² C m⁻² on the facing surfaces. Find fields in the ideal large-sheet approximation.
- 1.Each sheet alone produces magnitude σ/(2ε₀) on each side. Outside the pair the two fields oppose and cancel. Between the sheets both point from + to − and add.
- 2.The interior magnitude is σ/ε₀ = 1.70 × 10⁻²¹/(8.854 × 10⁻¹²) ≈ 1.92 × 10⁻¹⁰ N C⁻¹; the two exterior regions have zero field.
- 3.These are superposed fields in the ideal plane model, ignoring edge effects. A field’s sign and vector direction must be assigned before addition.
A uniformly charged thin spherical shell
Let shell radius be R, uniform surface density σ and total charge Q = 4πR²σ. Rotational symmetry about any axis through the centre requires the field at radius r to be radial, with the same signed radial component on a centred sphere. For r > R, the Gaussian sphere encloses all Q. For 0 < r < R it encloses none. Both cases use the same flux expression Eᵣ4πr², but different enclosed charges.
At the ideal surface, specify one-sided limits: Eᵣ(R⁻) = 0 and Eᵣ(R⁺) = σ/ε₀. A zero-thickness charged surface has a discontinuity; do not assign an unqualified single surface value. For a positive shell, its radial field graph is zero inside, jumps at R, and then decays as 1/r². A uniformly volume-charged solid sphere has the same exterior field for equal Q but a different interior: Q_enclosed grows as r³, giving Eᵣ = Qr/(4πε₀R³). It is not field-free inside.
Problem
A spherically symmetric charged sphere gives E = 1500 N C⁻¹ inward at r = 0.20 m. Find Q.
- 1.With outward r-hat positive, Eᵣ = −1500 N C⁻¹. Rearrange the exterior law: Q = Eᵣr²/k = −1500 × 0.040/(9 × 10⁹) = −6.67 × 10⁻⁹ C.
- 2.The measured point must be outside the sphere. The negative charge produces inward field; using magnitude alone would lose that sign.
A neutral spherical model with a nonzero interior field
Consider a historical model: a point nucleus +Ze at the centre of a uniform negative volume charge filling a sphere of radius R. The negative distribution totals −Ze, so its density is −3Ze/(4πR³). This is a mathematical exercise in enclosed charge, not an accurate modern electron-density model. At 0 < r < R, the Gaussian sphere encloses the nucleus and only fraction (r/R)³ of the negative charge. That fraction follows from the ratio of sphere volumes.
The bracket is positive for 0 < r < R, so E points outward even though negative charge is spread throughout the region. As r approaches R the two terms cancel. As r approaches zero the point-nucleus term dominates and diverges. These limits check both the sign and the model’s domain. The general lesson is to calculate Q_enclosed(r) before trying to solve for E(r).
Quick Quiz
Quiz
For an ideal infinite line, |E| varies with distance as
Explanation: Cylindrical wall area grows in proportion to r for fixed length.
An ideal isolated uniform infinite sheet produces magnitude
Explanation: Two pillbox faces contribute equally.
Inside a uniform thin spherical shell, E is zero because
Explanation: Symmetry is necessary to deduce local E from zero flux here.
A finite wire can approximate the infinite-wire result best
Explanation: End effects are then comparatively small.
For a uniformly volume-charged solid sphere, interior field magnitude is proportional to
Explanation: Q_enc ∝ r³ and the Gaussian sphere area ∝ r².
Practice Problems
- Derive the infinite-wire result and identify which Gaussian-surface portions carry flux.
- Derive the infinite-sheet result and explain why both face contributions add.
- A uniform shell has R = 0.10 m and Q = +4.0 nC. Find E at r = 0.05 m and 0.20 m and give one-sided surface values.
- A uniformly charged sphere of diameter 2.4 m has surface density 80.0 μC m⁻². Find charge and total outward flux.
- For a +Ze nucleus with uniform negative charge −Ze within R, derive Q_enclosed and E at r = R/2, and state the exterior field.
Cylindrical symmetry gives radial E(r). Use a coaxial cylinder of radius r and length L. End-face normals are along the wire and perpendicular to E, giving zero end flux. Curved flux is Eᵣ2πrL, with enclosed charge λL. Gauss’s law gives Eᵣ = λ/(2πε₀r). This needs the infinite uniform source symmetry, not merely a cylindrical surface.
Key Takeaways
• Choose a Gaussian surface only after establishing source symmetry. • An infinite uniform line gives E ∝ 1/r. • A symmetric infinite sheet gives |E| = |σ|/(2ε₀) on either side. • Finite-source approximations fail near edges and ends. • A uniform thin shell is field-free inside and point-charge-like outside. • Ideal surface fields require one-sided limits. • For a spherical volume model, find Q_enclosed(r) before E(r).
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…