Wave Optics · Lesson 3 of 8
Coherent Superposition and Interference
“Add light-wave amplitudes, derive interference intensity and explain coherence, visibility and energy redistribution.”
• Convert propagation path difference into relative phase. • Derive the equal-amplitude interference intensity relation. • Distinguish coherent from incoherent intensity addition. • Explain why unequal intensities or changing phase reduce dark-fringe contrast.
Two fields can cancel where both sources alone would illuminate
A ripple tank provides a useful starting model. Two oscillating needles driven with a stable phase relation create regions of enhanced and reduced motion. At an observation point the wave contributions add as displacements. Light similarly obeys field superposition: in a linear optical situation, total electric field is the vector sum of the contributions. The light sources need not disappear when the resulting field is small at one location.
For the scalar equations below, consider two light waves of the same frequency with electric fields along the same transverse direction. Then their signed components can be added algebraically. Waves with different polarisation directions require vector addition; perpendicular polarisations do not produce this same scalar interference term. The measured intensity averages very rapid optical oscillations rather than reporting the sign of the instantaneous field.
Separate source phase from phase acquired in travel
If two waves start in phase and travel through the same uniform medium, an extra path length λ is one extra cycle. An extra λ/2 is half a cycle. Define the signed propagation path difference Δ = ℓ₂ − ℓ₁. With the chosen time convention, a longer path delays the second contribution. Only the cosine of the relative phase will matter to the simple intensity relation, so reversing the sign convention does not alter its prediction.
A source phase offset must not be ignored. Equal path lengths give constructive interference only when the incident source contributions arrive in phase and have compatible polarisations. For two initially in-phase sources the sign of Δ only labels which contribution arrives later; whole wavelengths produce matching phase while half-integer wavelengths produce opposite phase.
Derive the equal-amplitude result
In the same medium, with otherwise identical beam conditions, intensity is proportional to the squared field amplitude. Let I₀ be the intensity from either contribution alone at the observation point. Squaring the resultant amplitude gives the observed relation. The factor of four at a bright point comes from doubling a field amplitude, not from creating four independent beams.
Problem
Two equal coherent contributions have propagation path difference 2λ and start in phase. Find combined intensity in terms of I₀.
- 1.Relative propagation phase is −4π. Since cos²(−2π) = 1, I = 4I₀.
- 2.With Δ = 2.5λ the relative phase would instead be −5π, giving cos²(−5π/2) = 0 and complete cancellation under the ideal equal-amplitude conditions.
Problem
At a bright point with Δ = λ, intensity is K. Find intensity at Δ = λ/3 for the same ideal equal contributions.
- 1.The bright value is K = 4I₀. At Δ = λ/3, |φ| = 2π/3, so I = 4I₀ cos²(π/3) = I₀.
- 2.Thus the requested intensity is K/4. Taking intensity proportional to path difference would have no wave-physics justification.
What coherence does and does not require
Coherent contributions maintain a definite relative phase over the measurement interval. Equal frequency is needed for a fixed phase difference in this simple monochromatic model, but two independent same-colour lamps generally do not maintain that relation. Their emission phases fluctuate independently. A detector then averages rapidly changing constructive and destructive arrangements rather than recording a stable spatial pattern.
For stable optical interference the common-source arrangement, path stability, finite source size and polarisation all matter. A detector that averages for too long relative to rapid phase drift can lose fringes. Conversely, some laboratory sources can be phase locked; “independent sources can never interfere” is too absolute. The ordinary two-lamp situation simply lacks the needed stable relative phase during observation.
Unequal intensities: destructive need not mean zero
The cross term comes from the product of the two field components. Its coefficient is related to amplitude product, hence the square root of intensity product. If one contribution is much weaker, it cannot completely cancel the stronger at any phase. This is a useful extension of the equal-amplitude source model and explains reduced contrast without inventing imperfect phase coherence.
Problem
The individual intensities at a point are 9 and 4 W/m². Find the coherent extrema and incoherent sum.
- 1.Square roots are 3 and 2 in consistent amplitude-related units. Thus I_max = (3 + 2)² = 25 W/m² and I_min = (3 − 2)² = 1 W/m².
- 2.The incoherent average is 9 + 4 = 13 W/m². Perfectly stable phase can still give a nonzero dark minimum if amplitudes differ.
Where does the energy go at a dark fringe?
Interference redistributes energy spatially. In a complete steady experiment, enhanced regions balance reduced regions when energy flow over the appropriate full pattern is accounted for. A detector placed at one dark location samples little local power; it does not show that both sources have stopped supplying energy. The average of the ideal equal-beam pattern over a full phase period is 2I₀, equal to the sum of the individual uniform contributions. For real finite beams, evaluate conservation over the actual illuminated region and boundaries, not an arbitrary single patch.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
Equal coherent in-phase waves each have intensity I₀. Combined intensity is
Explanation: Fields add to double amplitude, whose square gives four times one intensity.
A path difference λ/2 for initially in-phase equal contributions gives relative phase magnitude
Explanation: Path phase is 2πΔ/λ.
Two ordinary independent lamps do not show steady fringes mainly because
Explanation: Time averaging removes the fluctuating interference term.
For I₁ = 9 and I₂ = 4 in the same units, the minimum coherent intensity is
Explanation: Use (√9 − √4)² = 1.
At a dark interference fringe, energy is
Explanation: Spatial redistribution is consistent with energy conservation.
Practice Problems
- Derive I = 4I₀ cos²(φ/2) for two equal coherent same-polarisation waves.
- For equal initially in-phase beams, compare intensities at Δ = 0, λ/4, λ/2 and 3λ/4.
- Two coherent contributions have intensities 16 and 1 W/m². Find maxima, minima and incoherent average.
- Two waves have the same wavelength but a source phase difference π. Are equal path lengths bright or dark?
- Explain why instantaneous superposition still holds for incoherent light.
Write E₁ = a cosωt and E₂ = a cos(ωt + φ). The cosine-sum identity gives E = 2a cos(φ/2) cos(ωt + φ/2). The resultant amplitude magnitude is |2a cos(φ/2)|. Since one-source intensity I₀ is proportional to a² in the same medium, their combined intensity is 4I₀ cos²(φ/2). The sign of the amplitude prefactor changes phase, not intensity sign.
Key Takeaways
• In linear optics electric fields add before intensity is calculated. • One wavelength of extra path corresponds to a phase change of 2π. • Initially in-phase equal beams give maxima at integer path wavelengths and minima at half-integers. • Stable relative phase defines coherence for the observation interval. • Equal frequency alone does not ensure stable optical fringes. • Unequal beam strengths generally leave a nonzero destructive minimum. • Incoherent averaging removes the interference cross term. • Interference redistributes energy rather than destroying it.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…