Skip to lesson content

Lesson 6 of 8

Magnetism and Matter · Lesson 6 of 8

Diamagnetism and Paramagnetism

“Explain weak opposing and reinforcing responses to magnetic fields, including temperature and the Meissner effect.”

Learning Objectives

• Compare diamagnetic and paramagnetic microscopic responses. • Predict motion in a nonuniform field. • Interpret susceptibility signs and permeability near unity. • Explain the roles of thermal disorder and superconducting flux expulsion.

A stronger field can attract or repel a specimen

A small piece of aluminium is weakly attracted towards a stronger-field region, while a suitable diamagnetic specimen such as bismuth tends towards a weaker-field region. These responses are much weaker than the attraction of iron. The distinction is about how matter acquires a moment in an applied field. It is not a division between objects that have any magnetism and objects that have none.

For the following simple comparisons, take weak, approximately isotropic materials at a fixed temperature and a long-solenoid geometry when calculating internal fields. Compare magnetisation with H, whose direction is the same as the applied field direction in this setup. A nonuniform field is essential for a net translational tendency; an exactly uniform field cannot be used to claim that every small specimen must move bodily towards one side.

Diamagnetism: an induced response against the field

Electrons contribute orbital and spin magnetic moments. In many atoms and molecules the permanent contributions cancel in the unperturbed state. Applying a magnetic field changes the electronic state and induces a small net moment opposite to the applied direction. The response of electron motion has an opposition character often related qualitatively to induced currents. That current-loop picture provides intuition, but fixed classical orbits are not a complete microscopic theory of an atom.

For an ordinary weak diamagnet, χ is small and negative. Thus M points opposite H, and μr = 1 + χ is slightly below 1. In the long uniformly filled solenoid, B = μ₀(H + M) is slightly smaller than the empty-solenoid value. This does not usually mean B is reversed. With χ = −10⁻⁵ the fractional reduction is only one part in 100000.

Examples include bismuth, copper, lead, silicon, water, sodium chloride and nitrogen gas under ordinary stated conditions. Diamagnetic contributions occur in all matter, but can be masked by larger paramagnetic or ferromagnetic contributions. Saying that copper is diamagnetic refers to the dominant net response, not to an absence of electrons or magnetic interactions. Ordinary orbital diamagnetism is often only weakly temperature dependent within a phase, rather than obeying a universal inverse-temperature law.

Paramagnetism: a slight bias of pre-existing moments

Paramagnetic atoms, ions or molecules have nonzero permanent moments. Without an applied field, thermal disorder normally prevents a preferred bulk direction. Their vector sum averages to nearly zero. An applied field favours lower-energy orientations, giving a small statistical bias along the field. It does not generally make every atomic moment point exactly in the same direction. Competition between magnetic alignment and thermal disorder explains why the net effect is often weak.

Paramagnets have small positive χ and μr slightly greater than 1. In the long-solenoid model their M reinforces the applied contribution. Aluminium, oxygen gas, sodium, calcium and suitable copper salts are examples. Composition and physical conditions matter: copper metal and some copper compounds can have different dominant responses because their electronic structures differ.

DiamagnetParamagnetHHM opposite Hχ negativeM along Hχ small, positive
Weak material responses compared at the same H— Arrows show bulk response direction; lengths are schematic, not a strength scale.

Temperature and saturation

For many dilute systems of weakly interacting local moments in a sufficiently weak field, increasing absolute temperature reduces the alignment bias. In that restricted regime Curie’s relation gives χ proportional to 1/T. This is a useful model, not a law for every paramagnet: conduction-electron paramagnetism and interacting systems can behave differently. Use kelvin, not Celsius, in inverse-temperature comparisons.

A limited temperature model for local-moment paramagnetsLaTeX
C is the Curie constant in kelvin for dimensionless χ; T is absolute temperature. This is a simple weak-field model of suitable local moments, not a universal material law.

Cooling a suitable paramagnet or increasing the field increases its alignment. At very low temperature or strong field, moment alignment approaches saturation. A linear law cannot continue indefinitely because the available microscopic moments are finite. Do not extrapolate χ = C/T to predict arbitrarily large M at T = 0. The assumptions fail before that limit.

A small sign change in susceptibility

Problem
Two weak materials fill otherwise identical long solenoids with H = 1000 A/m. One has χ = −2.0 × 10⁻⁵ and the other χ = +2.0 × 10⁻⁵. Compare M and B.

  1. 1.M is −0.020 A/m for the diamagnet and +0.020 A/m for the paramagnet, measured along the common positive H direction.
  2. 2.The empty-solenoid value is B₀ = μ₀H = 1.256637 × 10⁻³ T.
  3. 3.Each field differs from B₀ by μ₀ × 0.020 = 2.5133 × 10⁻⁸ T, downward for the diamagnet and upward for the paramagnet.
  4. 4.The opposite signs change the response type, but neither material reverses the dominant applied field. Similar numerical field magnitudes can conceal different responses.

Why the field gradient determines motion

A paramagnet gains a larger favourable response in a stronger field and tends towards that region; a diamagnet tends towards lower field. A spatial field gradient permits unequal forces across the specimen. These are weak bulk tendencies under the stated conditions, not a rule that a uniform field always produces a net force. A suspended rod or fluid experiment must be sensitive enough that friction, gravity and convection do not mask the response.

Predict and resolve

A weak diamagnet is placed in an exactly uniform field. Will it necessarily accelerate away from the magnet? No. Opposing magnetisation describes its internal response; translation requires a field gradient. A real magnet usually supplies that gradient, but the ideal uniform-field statement must be kept separate.

Superconductivity and the Meissner effect

A material in its superconducting Meissner state expels magnetic field from its bulk, apart from a thin surface penetration region. In the ideal bulk description B = 0, so B = μ₀(H + M) gives M = −H, χ = −1 and μr = 0. This is perfect diamagnetism in the appropriate state, much stronger than ordinary weak diamagnetism. It is not the normal-state response of every cooled metal.

Superconductivity requires suitable material and conditions below its critical temperature, and field or current limits also apply. Some superconductors permit vortices and partial field penetration in a mixed state. Thus “a superconductor always has zero B under any field” is false. Zero electrical resistance alone is also insufficient to explain the Meissner effect: equilibrium flux expulsion is a distinct property. Magnetic levitation can exploit diamagnetism and, in some superconductors, flux pinning; not all levitating trains use the same mechanism.

A temperature comparison in the correct regime

Problem
A local-moment paramagnet has χ = 6.0 × 10⁻⁴ at 300 K and follows χ = C/T over the range considered. At fixed H, estimate χ and the magnetisation ratio at 450 K.

  1. 1.The Curie constant is C = χT = 6.0 × 10⁻⁴ × 300 = 0.18 K.
  2. 2.At 450 K, χ = 0.18/450 = 4.0 × 10⁻⁴.
  3. 3.At the same H, Mnew/Mold = χnew/χold = 2/3. Thermal disorder has reduced the net alignment, within the assumed weak-field range.

A quantum theory is needed to explain superconducting behaviour. The Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer theory was developed in 1957 and was recognised by the 1972 Nobel Prize in Physics. The present introductory model uses its observable bulk consequences without attempting a microscopic derivation. It also does not assume that every superconducting material is an ordinary elemental metal.

Quick Quiz

Quiz

Quick check

An ordinary weak diamagnet has

Its induced bulk response opposes H but normally reduces B only slightly.

Quick check

The net moment of an ordinary zero-field paramagnet averages nearly to zero mainly because

Permanent moments can exist but their differently directed contributions cancel on average.

Quick check

In a nonuniform field a weak paramagnet tends towards

Its positive response favours the stronger-field region under the stated conditions.

Quick check

In a suitable Curie-law regime, doubling kelvin temperature at fixed H makes M

M = CH/T, so fixed C and H give inverse-temperature dependence.

Quick check

The ideal superconducting Meissner bulk has

Bulk expulsion gives H + M = 0. The Meissner state has material and field limits.

Practice Problems

Practice Problems
  1. Classify χ = −8 × 10⁻⁶ and χ = +8 × 10⁻⁶ and give their relative permeabilities.
  2. Explain why a diamagnet can have induced M even when its unperturbed atoms have zero net permanent moment.
  3. A local-moment sample obeys χ = C/T and has M = 0.12 A/m at 240 K for a fixed weak H. Find M at 360 K.
  4. Why does negative susceptibility alone not prove that a specimen in uniform B experiences a net force?
  5. Use B = μ₀(H + M) to find ideal Meissner-state χ and explain a limit of the conclusion.

The negative value indicates a weak diamagnet with μr = 0.999992. The positive value indicates a weak paramagnet with μr = 1.000008. Their M vectors oppose and follow H respectively. Neither is a large field enhancement.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

• Diamagnetism is an induced opposing contribution and is present in all matter. • Ordinary weak diamagnets have χ below zero and μr slightly below one. • Paramagnets contain permanent moments whose thermal disorder limits bulk alignment. • Weak paramagnets have small positive χ and μr slightly above one. • A field gradient permits diamagnets and paramagnets to move towards weaker and stronger fields respectively. • For suitable weakly interacting local moments, χ can vary as 1/T within a limited range. • Strong fields and low temperatures can lead to saturation and failure of linear extrapolation. • Ideal Meissner-state bulk flux expulsion is perfect diamagnetism under specific conditions.

Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.

Loading your progress…