Dual Nature of Radiation and Matter · Lesson 3 of 7
Photons and Einstein’s Photoelectric Equation
“Build the photon energy model from photoelectric observations and use conservation of energy to explain threshold and stopping potential.”
• Explain why classical continuous-energy absorption fails for the photoelectric observations. • Apply the photon-energy postulate and distinguish it from a derived relation. • Derive the photoelectric energy balance and threshold relations. • Solve emission and stopping-potential problems without accepting negative kinetic energies.
Which observations need a new explanation?
Interference and diffraction show that light has wave behaviour. A classical electromagnetic wave carries energy spread through space; increasing intensity increases field amplitude and energy delivery rate. The difficulty is not the existence of waves but the assumption that an individual electron absorbs energy continuously from this classical field. Photoelectric measurements separate brightness from electron energy in a way that this simple classical picture does not predict.
| Observation | Difficulty for continuous accumulation | What must be explained |
|---|---|---|
| Higher intensity raises current but not Kmax at fixed frequency. | Greater energy delivery to each electron should affect its escape energy in a simple accumulation model. | Number of events and energy per event have separate controls. |
| A material-dependent threshold frequency exists. | A slow enough accumulation could eventually supply escape energy even below threshold. | Frequency, rather than total delivered energy alone, governs escape. |
| Very weak above-threshold light produces prompt events. | An electron intercepting a small fraction of a weak spread-out wave would require an accumulation interval. | A successful event can transfer the required energy in one interaction. |
The classical theory does explain why more incident energy can yield more total emitted charge, so intensity dependence of current alone is not the decisive test. Threshold, stopping-potential behaviour and lack of the predicted accumulation delay must be considered together. This conclusion does not discard successful wave explanations of propagation, interference or diffraction.
The photon-energy postulate
Einstein proposed in 1905 that radiation transfers energy in quanta. In the ordinary photoelectric process one photon is absorbed in an event that can release an electron. The energy of that quantum is hf. This is a physical postulate supported by experiments, not something that follows from algebra or from conservation of energy alone. Conservation then tells us how that specified energy is distributed.
At one fixed frequency, increasing intensity increases photon arrival rate per area. It does not increase hf for each photon. A brighter red beam can deliver more energy per second than a dim ultraviolet beam while each ultraviolet photon still has more energy. Total energy delivered over time and energy transferred in a single event answer different questions.
Derivation: account for the absorbed energy
Choose a fixed clean surface, weak or moderate illumination, one-photon absorption and no significant field-induced barrier change. Consider an electron in a most favourable initial state that reaches the surface without additional energy losses. It needs φ to escape. The remainder of the absorbed energy is its maximum kinetic energy outside. Electrons starting at lower energy or undergoing collisions emerge with less kinetic energy; not all photoelectrons attain the maximum.
Dimensional check: all terms are energies. Limiting check: as hf approaches φ from above, Kmax approaches zero. Increasing φ at fixed f reduces Kmax and can prevent emission. An additional photon does not normally lend its energy to the same escaping electron in this regime; it creates another opportunity for an independent event. Intense pulsed fields can cause multiphoton emission, which lies outside the elementary single-photon model used here.
Derivation: threshold frequency and longest usable wavelength
At the ideal threshold the most favourable outgoing electron has zero kinetic energy, so set Kmax = 0 in the energy balance. This gives hf₀ = φ. Divide by h to obtain f₀. Because f = c/λ in vacuum, the corresponding wavelength is λ₀ = c/f₀ = hc/φ. Frequencies above f₀ mean wavelengths below λ₀. The threshold wavelength is the longest usable wavelength, not the shortest.
Higher work function therefore means higher threshold frequency but shorter threshold wavelength. Doubling the frequency does not generally double Kmax, because φ is subtracted once per emitted electron. Likewise, halving wavelength increases photon energy, but the electron’s maximum energy still requires subtraction of the work function.
Derivation: connect the model to the voltage measurement
The previous lesson measured Kmax using a retarding field, giving Kmax = eVₛ. Substitute this into Einstein’s balance and divide every term by the positive charge magnitude e. The resulting stopping magnitude is linear in f. This is a testable prediction tying a microscopic event to an accessible voltage measurement.
Problem
A caesium surface has φ = 2.14 eV and is illuminated at f = 6.00 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Find Kmax, Vₛ and vmax.
- 1.First find photon energy: hf = 3.976 × 10⁻¹⁹ J = 2.481 eV using h = 4.13567 × 10⁻¹⁵ eV s.
- 2.The photon energy exceeds φ. Kmax = 2.481 − 2.14 = 0.341 eV = 5.47 × 10⁻²⁰ J.
- 3.Vₛ = Kmax/e = 0.341 V. The cutoff collector voltage is −0.341 V.
- 4.vmax = √(2Kmax/mₑ) = 3.46 × 10⁵ m/s, much smaller than c. Higher intensity at this frequency would raise the count rate without raising this edge.
Problem
For a surface with φ = 2.14 eV, illumination gives Vₛ = 0.600 V. Find the threshold frequency and incident wavelength.
- 1.The threshold obeys f₀ = φ/h = 2.14/(4.13567 × 10⁻¹⁵) = 5.17 × 10¹⁴ Hz.
- 2.The incident photon must supply 2.14 + 0.600 = 2.740 eV, rather than just the outgoing 0.600 eV.
- 3.Using hc = 1239.84 eV nm gives λ = 1239.84/2.740 = 452.5 nm, approximately 453 nm.
- 4.Using heavily rounded h, c and e can shift the last nanometre. The wavelength is shorter than the threshold wavelength, about 579 nm, as required.
What prompt emission does and does not mean
A successful absorption supplies the quantum energy in one event. Reducing intensity makes such events rarer, without requiring an electron to accumulate fractions of photon energy over a long time. There may be a longer random wait for the first photon to arrive at a small region under extremely weak light. That waiting time is not the classical energy-accumulation delay. Emission, electron transport and the response of a real measuring instrument also have finite time scales.
A metal needs 4.20 eV to release an electron and receives 330 nm light. The photon energy is 1239.84/330 = 3.76 eV. No ordinary single-photon emission occurs. Writing Kmax = −0.44 eV is a diagnostic that emission is forbidden; it is not a physical energy for an emitted electron.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
Why does brighter below-threshold light fail to cause ordinary photoemission?
In the one-photon regime, escape requires hf ≥ φ for an individual event; extra below-threshold photons do not simply pool their energy into one event.
An absorbed photon has 5.0 eV and φ = 2.0 eV. What is Kmax?
Energy conservation gives Kmax = Eγ − φ = 3.0 eV. Some emitted electrons have less than this maximum.
If φ doubles, what happens to threshold wavelength?
λ₀ = hc/φ, so with h and c fixed the longest usable wavelength varies inversely with work function.
Which statement correctly describes hf?
Conservation constrains energy bookkeeping after the photon energy hf is specified. It cannot determine the postulate itself.
Under very weak above-threshold light, what can increase?
Weak light lowers event rate. Once a suitable photon is absorbed, its energy is transferred in an event rather than accumulated continuously from a spread-out classical field.
Practice Problems
- Light with photon energy 3.50 eV falls on a surface with φ = 2.10 eV. Find Kmax, Vₛ and vmax.
- A surface has φ = 2.50 eV. Calculate f₀ and λ₀, then test 600 nm and 400 nm light.
- Derive the change of stopping magnitude when the frequency increases by Δf without changing the emitter.
- A source sends twice as many photons per second at the same above-threshold frequency. Explain the changes in total power, saturation current and Kmax.
- Why do electrons emitted by monochromatic light have a range of kinetic energies rather than all having hf − φ?
Energy conservation gives Kmax = 1.40 eV = 2.243 × 10⁻¹⁹ J. Thus Vₛ = 1.40 V. For a nonrelativistic electron, vmax = √(2Kmax/mₑ) = 7.02 × 10⁵ m/s. This is about 0.00234c, validating the speed approximation.
Key Takeaways
• Classical continuous absorption fails to explain threshold, energy-edge and timing observations together. • A photon transfers energy hf in an elementary absorption event. • Kmax = hf − φ follows from energy conservation for the most favourable escaping electron. • f₀ = φ/h and λ₀ = hc/φ describe the threshold in frequency and wavelength. • eVₛ = hf − φ connects photon absorption to a measurable retarding voltage. • A negative calculated excess energy means no single-photon emission. • At fixed frequency intensity changes the event rate, not photon energy.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…