Dual Nature of Radiation and Matter · Lesson 4 of 7
Photoelectric Graphs and Quantitative Reasoning
“Extract physical constants and surface energies from graphs and solve inverse photoelectric problems with explicit units and signs.”
• Interpret slopes and intercepts of stopping-magnitude and kinetic-energy graphs. • Infer work function or threshold from measurements. • Calculate threshold from a measured maximum electron speed. • Identify unphysical extrapolations and evaluate simple measurement uncertainty.
A straight line carries several measurements
A set of photoelectric measurements can do more than show that light ejects electrons. For a stable surface, plot positive stopping magnitude Vₛ vertically and incident frequency f horizontally. The energy-balance model predicts a straight line. Its slope probes a universal constant; its intercept probes the particular surface. A common graph error is to confuse this positive stopping magnitude with the negative collector voltage used to stop the current.
At the horizontal intercept Vₛ = 0, so f = f₀ = φ/h. Extending the mathematical line to f = 0 gives a vertical intercept −φ/e. That extension is a device for reading parameters; it is not a prediction of negative kinetic energy or negative stopping magnitude for nonexistent photoelectrons. Draw the physical data only for frequencies producing emission and distinguish any dashed extrapolation.
Two metals share slope h/e but generally have different horizontal intercepts. At a frequency above both thresholds, the smaller-work-function surface has the larger stopping magnitude. Their vertical separation is (φ₂ − φ₁)/e. Higher threshold does not mean a steeper line. If the slope differs strongly between nominally clean surfaces, investigate frequency calibration, voltage offsets or data range before interpreting it as a change in h.
Millikan’s precise photoelectric measurements tested the predicted linear relationship for alkali-metal surfaces. Combining the measured slope with the independently known electron charge gave a value of h consistent with determinations from other radiation experiments. Although he initially questioned Einstein’s explanation, the measured relationship supported it. This is stronger evidence than obtaining a straight line from arbitrary teaching numbers: independent methods agreed on the same constant.
Choose the units of the kinetic-energy axis carefully
If the horizontal axis is labelled f/(10¹⁴ Hz), each displayed horizontal unit represents 10¹⁴ Hz. A numerical slope of 0.414 V per displayed unit corresponds to 4.14 × 10⁻¹⁵ V s, not 0.414 V s. Always recover the real axis units before calculating a constant. Graphs against wavelength are not straight lines: Vₛ = hc/(eλ) − φ/e is linear in 1/λ, not in λ.
Problem
A surface gives Vₛ = 0.40 V at 6.0 × 10¹⁴ Hz and 1.20 V at 8.0 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Infer h and φ from these rounded data.
- 1.The slope is (1.20 − 0.40)/[(8.0 − 6.0) × 10¹⁴] = 4.00 × 10⁻¹⁵ V s.
- 2.Multiplying by e gives h ≈ 6.41 × 10⁻³⁴ J s. Rounded teaching data need not reproduce the accepted h exactly.
- 3.The extrapolated intercept is b = 0.40 − (4.00 × 10⁻¹⁵)(6.0 × 10¹⁴) = −2.00 V. Thus φ/e = 2.00 V and φ = 2.00 eV.
- 4.The threshold is −b/s = 5.00 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Substituting either measurement into the fitted line reproduces the voltage.
Recover an unknown work function
An inverse problem starts with measured outgoing energy and asks how much photon energy was spent escaping. First determine hf from the incident wavelength or frequency. Then subtract the maximum kinetic energy, which may be supplied directly, through a stopping measurement, or through vmax. Do not subtract a voltage from an energy without the e conversion. In eV, however, the numerical Kmax equals the numerical stopping magnitude in volts for one electron.
Problem
A 488 nm beam produces stopping magnitude 0.38 V. Determine the emitter work function.
- 1.The photon energy is hc/λ = 1239.84/488 = 2.54066 eV.
- 2.The maximum outgoing energy is eVₛ = 0.38 eV. Conservation requires φ = 2.54066 − 0.38 = 2.16066 eV ≈ 2.16 eV.
- 3.As a check, the threshold wavelength is 1239.84/2.16 ≈ 574 nm, longer than the 488 nm illumination. The beam is correctly above threshold.
Problem
At f = 7.21 × 10¹⁴ Hz, the maximum emitted-electron speed is 6.0 × 10⁵ m/s. Find f₀.
- 1.First compute kinetic energy: Kmax = ½(9.109 × 10⁻³¹)(6.0 × 10⁵)² = 1.640 × 10⁻¹⁹ J.
- 2.Divide by h to express that energy as a frequency difference: Kmax/h = 2.475 × 10¹⁴ Hz.
- 3.The balance Kmax = h(f − f₀) gives f₀ = 7.21 × 10¹⁴ − 2.475 × 10¹⁴ = 4.74 × 10¹⁴ Hz.
- 4.The inferred work function is about 1.96 eV. It is positive and the illuminating frequency exceeds threshold; these are necessary consistency checks.
Compare changes without recalculating everything
For a single surface, work function cancels when two photoelectric balances are subtracted. A frequency increase Δf gives ΔKmax = hΔf and ΔVₛ = (h/e)Δf. For two surfaces at the same frequency, photon energy cancels instead, leaving a difference determined by the work functions. Decide what is held fixed before using proportional reasoning; doubling f is not equivalent to doubling f − f₀.
A learner draws Vₛ directly proportional to f through the origin. That would imply zero work function. A real metal generally has a nonzero frequency intercept. Linear dependence means a straight line; direct proportionality additionally requires a zero intercept.
Uncertainty and the difference between data and a model
The numerical examples above are teaching data, not claims of new experimental measurements. In an actual experiment, estimate a line from several points. A constant voltage offset changes the intercept and the inferred work function, but not the ideal slope; a frequency-scale error changes the slope. Finite spectral bandwidth and a small high-frequency contaminant can alter the observed energy edge. For a fixed wavelength, uncertainty in Vₛ alone gives work-function uncertainty magnitude eδVₛ, or the same numerical amount in eV as δVₛ in volts.
If a formal calculation gives f₀ < 0 for an ordinary metal, the data or assumptions need checking. Likewise a measured speed whose kinetic energy exceeds hf cannot be explained by photon absorption alone without another energy source or an error. Conservation is a stronger check than an algebraically tidy answer.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
What is the slope of Vₛ versus f in SI units?
Divide eVₛ = hf − φ by e. The frequency coefficient is h/e and volts per hertz equal V s.
Two surfaces have different work functions. Their ideal Vₛ–f lines are what?
The slope h/e is universal, while f₀ = φ/h depends on the surface.
A line extrapolates to −2.3 V at f = 0. What is φ?
The vertical intercept is −φ/e. Its magnitude in volts equals the work function’s numerical value in eV.
For one surface, frequency increases by 1.0 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Approximately how much does Vₛ rise?
ΔVₛ = (4.13567 × 10⁻¹⁵)(1.0 × 10¹⁴) V = 0.414 V, provided both frequencies cause emission.
Which graph is linear for a fixed surface in the ideal model?
Vₛ = (hc/e)(1/λ) − φ/e. The varying term is 1/λ, not λ itself.
Practice Problems
- The slope of a stopping-magnitude versus frequency graph is 4.12 × 10⁻¹⁵ V s. Calculate h and compare it with 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴ J s.
- A surface has f₀ = 3.3 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Predict the stopping magnitude for f = 8.2 × 10¹⁴ Hz.
- At a common frequency above both thresholds, surface A has φA = 2.0 eV and surface B has φB = 2.8 eV. Compare their stopping magnitudes and frequency intercepts.
- A 500 nm beam gives Vₛ = 0.50 ± 0.02 V. Assuming wavelength is exact, estimate φ and its voltage-related uncertainty.
- A student extends Vₛ = (h/e)(f − f₀) below f₀ and reports a negative maximum kinetic energy. Explain the error and describe the physical graph there.
h = es = (1.602176634 × 10⁻¹⁹)(4.12 × 10⁻¹⁵) = 6.601 × 10⁻³⁴ J s. The value is about 0.38% below 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴. Charge times V s is J s. A small experimental deviation does not imply a material-dependent Planck constant.
Key Takeaways
• The slope of Vₛ versus f is h/e; the slope of Kmax in joules versus f is h. • The frequency intercept is φ/h; the extrapolated voltage intercept is −φ/e. • Different stable surfaces give parallel ideal stopping-magnitude lines. • Axis scale factors and energy units must be included when reading a slope. • Use energy conservation to infer work function or threshold from voltage and speed. • Below-threshold line extensions do not represent negative kinetic energies. • Voltage offsets, spectral bandwidth and surface changes can bias inferred parameters.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…