Dual Nature of Radiation and Matter · Lesson 7 of 7
Chapter Summary and Practice
“Synthesise emission evidence, photon energy transfer and matter waves, then solve mixed conceptual, graphical and numerical problems.”
• Connect experimental observations with photon energy and momentum. • Select and apply the correct energy balance for emission, stopping and acceleration. • Interpret graphs and compare wavelengths under explicit fixed conditions. • Solve mixed problems while checking assumptions, units and physical feasibility.
One chapter, two linked questions
The first question is how radiation exchanges energy with matter. Surface electrons can move inside a metal but need energy to escape. Experiments measure both the rate of collected charge and the largest initial kinetic energy. Intensity changes the number of ordinary emission events at fixed frequency; frequency changes the energy transferred in one event. A threshold, a linear energy edge and prompt absorption require quantised exchange rather than simple continuous energy accumulation.
The second question is whether particles of matter can have wave behaviour. De Broglie connects momentum to wavelength. Electrons register as local charged events but can produce a diffraction pattern from many events. The chapter therefore links local exchanges with wave amplitudes rather than replacing all physics by either classical rays or classical waves.
Keep the experimental meanings distinct
| Quantity | Meaning | What controls it in the ordinary model |
|---|---|---|
| Photocurrent i | Charge arriving per second; A | Photon rate, emission efficiency and collection. |
| Saturation current iₛ | All available emitted electrons collected per second times e | Illumination and surface emission rate, not further increases in an already saturating collector voltage. |
| Stopping magnitude Vₛ | Retarding energy edge divided by e; V | Frequency and work function; collector cutoff is −Vₛ. |
| Work function φ | Minimum surface escape energy; J or eV | Material and surface condition. |
| Photon energy Eγ | Energy per quantum; J or eV | Frequency or vacuum wavelength. |
| De Broglie wavelength λ | Momentum-related wave phase scale; m | Momentum, not geometric particle size. |
A retarding field can produce zero collected current even while electrons leave and return to the emitter. Conversely, nonzero current at zero applied voltage can result from electrons’ initial kinetic energy. The meter and stopping voltage therefore answer different questions. When changing frequency, equal intensity does not guarantee equal saturation current: energy per photon and emission efficiency can change. This qualification preserves the reliable comparison of cutoff positions.
Formula reference with meaning and conditions
| Relationship | Symbols and units | Use and limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Eγ = hf = hc/λ | h in J s; f in Hz; Eγ in J; λ in m | Energy per photon; λ and c are vacuum values. |
| pγ = Eγ/c = h/λ | pγ in kg m/s | Photon momentum magnitude in vacuum; never substitute p = mv with zero photon rest mass. |
| Ṅ = P/(hf) | P in W; Ṅ in s⁻¹ | Use the intercepted monochromatic power; total count is ṄΔt. |
| iₛ = eηṄ | e in C; η dimensionless; iₛ in A | Ordinary one-photon emission with specified quantum efficiency and full collection. |
| Kmax = hf − φ = eVₛ | Energies in J or consistently in eV; Vₛ in V | Only where photoemission is allowed; no negative emitted kinetic energy. |
| f₀ = φ/h; λ₀ = hc/φ | f₀ in Hz; λ₀ in m | Ideal threshold and longest usable wavelength; surface must be specified. |
| Vₛ = (h/e)f − φ/e | Slope h/e in V s | Physical line above threshold; extension below is only mathematical. |
| vmax = √(2Kmax/mₑ) | vmax in m/s; Kmax in J | Nonrelativistic emitted electron. |
| λ = h/p | p in kg m/s; λ in m | General momentum–wavelength relation using the appropriate momentum. |
| λ = h/√(2mK) | m in kg; K in J | Slow massive particle, K ≪ mc². |
| λe = h/√(2mₑeU) | U in V; λe in m | Electron accelerated nearly from rest without losses and still slow. |
| hfmax ≈ eU; λmin ≈ hc/(eU) | U is accelerating magnitude in V | Ideal X-ray endpoint for nearly complete single-event transfer to a heavy target. |
| Quantity | SI dimension | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Planck constant h | [M L² T⁻¹] | J s |
| Stopping magnitude Vₛ | [M L² T⁻³ I⁻¹] | V |
| Work function φ | [M L² T⁻²] | J or eV |
| Threshold frequency f₀ | [T⁻¹] | Hz |
| Matter wavelength λ | [L] | m |
| Momentum magnitude p | [M L T⁻¹] | kg m/s |
In the dimension notation, M, L, T and I denote mass, length, time and electric current. For example, a volt is energy per charge: dividing kg m²/s² by A s gives kg m²/(A s³). Multiplying a voltage by charge therefore restores energy dimensions. Likewise, h/p has dimensions of length. These checks can reject an incorrect formula, though correct dimensions alone do not prove a physical law.
The constants used here are h = 6.62607015 × 10⁻³⁴ J s, e = 1.602176634 × 10⁻¹⁹ C and c = 299792458 m/s. Useful rounded constants are h = 4.13567 × 10⁻¹⁵ eV s for photon energies in eV and hc = 1239.84 eV nm. For voltage–frequency slopes, h/e = 4.13567 × 10⁻¹⁵ V s. The electron mass is approximately 9.109 × 10⁻³¹ kg. Keep enough digits during intermediate arithmetic and round only the reported result.
Rebuild the essential derivations
For photoemission, start with the most favourable electron and account for one absorbed photon: hf = φ + Kmax. Setting Kmax = 0 defines threshold hf₀ = φ. Replacing Kmax by the measured retarding energy eVₛ gives a straight line of slope h/e. The slope is universal; the threshold and intercept depend on the surface. This chain explains why higher frequency changes electron energy while higher intensity at fixed frequency changes event rate.
For slow matter, begin with K = ½mv² and p = mv. Eliminating v yields p² = 2mK. Insert this into the de Broglie hypothesis λ = h/p; then use K = eU only when the particle is an electron accelerated nearly from rest without losses. Neither Einstein’s photon-energy postulate nor de Broglie’s hypothesis is proved by these rearrangements: the rearrangements give predictions to test.
A reliable problem-solving route
First identify whether the question concerns the incident photon, the initially emitted electron, its subsequent motion, or the whole beam. Then write the relevant energy balance. Convert nanometres to metres for SI calculations, or use hc in eV nm consistently. Check the emission condition before calculating a stopping magnitude or speed. If a current is requested, ask for photon rate, quantum efficiency and collection conditions; energy per photon alone does not determine a current.
Problem
A surface gives Vₛ = 0.90 V under 400 nm light. Predict its threshold wavelength, stopping magnitude under 500 nm light, and the de Broglie wavelength of the fastest 400 nm photoelectrons.
- 1.At 400 nm the photon energy is 3.0996 eV, so φ = 3.0996 − 0.90 = 2.1996 eV.
- 2.The threshold wavelength is λ₀ = 1239.84/2.1996 = 563.7 nm.
- 3.At 500 nm Eγ = 2.4797 eV, so emission is allowed and Kmax = 0.2801 eV. The stopping magnitude is 0.280 V.
- 4.The fastest original electrons have Kmax = 0.90 eV. Their wavelength is h/√(2mₑKmax) = 1.22643/√0.90 = 1.29 nm.
- 5.The 400 nm incident wavelength and 1.29 nm electron wavelength refer to different particles and different momenta. The electron receives only the energy left after escape.
Problem
Beams at f and 2f deliver the same photon rate to a surface whose threshold lies below f. Assume equal emission efficiency. Compare power, saturation current and Kmax.
- 1.Each high-frequency photon has twice the energy, so at equal photon rate the 2f beam has twice the power.
- 2.With equal η and complete collection, iₛ = eηṄ is the same for both beams.
- 3.Their maximum emitted energies are hf − φ and 2hf − φ. The difference is hf; the ratio is not generally 2 because the same work function is subtracted from both.
- 4.If instead power were fixed, the photon rate at 2f would halve. State the fixed condition before comparing currents.
Misconceptions to diagnose rather than memorise
| Tempting statement | Correct reasoning |
|---|---|
| Brighter means faster photoelectrons. | At fixed frequency and surface, brightness changes event rate, not the energy edge. |
| Any negative result is a negative kinetic energy. | A negative hf − φ means no ordinary emission; inspect the model’s allowed domain. |
| Every photon releases one electron. | That is an ideal efficiency assumption, not a general experimental law. |
| A higher threshold means a steeper stopping-voltage line. | The slope is h/e; threshold shifts the intercept. |
| A matter wave is an electromagnetic wave around a charged particle. | Quantum amplitudes describe matter waves, including neutral particles. |
| Doubling electron accelerating voltage halves wavelength. | For a slow electron λ ∝ U⁻¹ᐟ², so voltage must quadruple to halve λ. |
| Wave–particle duality abolishes conservation laws. | Total energy and momentum remain conserved in the complete interaction. |
A connected picture of the evidence
The electron-emission experiments establish a surface energy cost and a way to measure escaping charge. The photoelectric energy edge connects that cost with photon frequency. Photon momentum unites radiation wavelength with h/p. Electron diffraction then shows that the same wavelength–momentum relation applies beyond light. What a given apparatus measures—an energy edge, a count rate or an angular probability pattern—determines which part of this connected description is most useful.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
Which pair separates electron rate from maximum initial electron energy most directly?
Current counts charge arrival rate. Stopping magnitude gives an energy edge through eVₛ; neither measurement replaces the other.
A 3 eV photon hits a surface with φ = 4 eV in the ordinary regime. What follows?
One photon cannot supply the minimum escape cost. Negative algebraic excess energy does not describe a real emitted electron.
An electron and a photon have the same wavelength. What must be equal?
Both satisfy p = h/λ. Their energy–momentum relations differ, so equal wavelength fixes momentum but not speed or energy.
Which change halves a slow electron’s wavelength after acceleration from rest?
λ ∝ U⁻¹ᐟ². A factor 4 in voltage produces a factor 2 in momentum and a factor 1/2 in wavelength.
Two stable surfaces give parallel Vₛ–f lines with different frequency intercepts. What differs?
The common slope is h/e. Different intercepts reflect f₀ = φ/h and therefore different surface escape energies.
Practice Problems
- An electron beam accelerated through 25 kV strikes a heavy target. Find the ideal maximum X-ray frequency and minimum wavelength.
- A surface with φ = 2.20 eV is illuminated at 7.00 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Find Kmax in eV and joules, the stopping magnitude and vmax.
- A cutoff is measured at collector voltage −1.20 V. Find the maximum initial kinetic energy and the energy of such an electron after a +2.00 V accelerating potential from the emitter.
- A 600 nm beam of power 3.00 mW is fully intercepted. Calculate photon energy, momentum, arrival rate and the speed of a hydrogen atom of mass 1.67 × 10⁻²⁷ kg with the same momentum as one photon.
- Teaching data give a Vₛ–f slope of 4.10 × 10⁻¹⁵ V s and horizontal intercept 4.80 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Infer h, φ and the fitted Vₛ at 8.00 × 10¹⁴ Hz.
- A material has f₀ = 5.00 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Find its longest threshold wavelength and the stopping magnitude at 7.50 × 10¹⁴ Hz.
- A metal has φ = 4.20 eV. Test 330 nm and 250 nm light for photoemission and predict what a tenfold intensity increase at 330 nm does.
- Light of frequency 8.00 × 10¹⁴ Hz ejects electrons with maximum speed 5.00 × 10⁵ m/s. Find the threshold frequency and work function.
- A 450 nm beam gives a stopping magnitude of 0.80 V. Calculate φ, then decide whether 650 nm light can eject electrons from the same surface.
- For a 0.020 kg projectile at 500 m/s and a 1.0 × 10⁻¹² kg speck at 0.10 m/s, calculate de Broglie wavelengths. Compare them with a 100 eV electron.
- Show that the electromagnetic wavelength of a photon equals h/pγ. Then compare an electron and a photon with common wavelength 0.200 nm.
- A 400 nm beam of intercepted power 2.00 μW illuminates a surface with φ = 2.00 eV and η = 0.10. Find saturation current and stopping magnitude, then predict both if power doubles.
The available kinetic energy is eU = 25 keV = 4.0054 × 10⁻¹⁵ J. The endpoint assumes essentially this entire energy becomes one photon: fmax = eU/h = 6.04 × 10¹⁸ Hz. λmin = hc/(eU) = 0.0496 nm. Other photons can carry less energy and have longer wavelengths; one should not identify this endpoint with the mean spectrum.
Key Takeaways
• Work function is an escape energy; mobile electrons are not automatically free to leave a surface. • Photocurrent and stopping magnitude measure different aspects of photoemission. • The photon balance hf = φ + Kmax explains threshold and the frequency-dependent energy edge. • Photon power and photon rate are linked by P = Ṅhf; efficiency is needed for an electron-current prediction. • Photon momentum is h/λ; the same wavelength–momentum relation extends to matter. • For slow particles wavelength scales inversely with momentum and with the square root of kinetic energy. • Always specify the fixed comparison conditions, sign convention and regime of validity. • Wave and particle aspects describe experimental evidence within a common quantum framework.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…
Previous · Lesson 6
Matter Waves and Electron Diffraction
Next
End of chapter