Skip to lesson content

Lesson 6 of 7

Dual Nature of Radiation and Matter · Lesson 6 of 7

Matter Waves and Electron Diffraction

“Use the de Broglie relation to connect momentum with wavelength and understand why quantum wave effects depend on experimental scale.”

Learning Objectives

• State the de Broglie hypothesis and distinguish it from a classical trajectory claim. • Calculate wavelength from momentum, speed, kinetic energy and accelerating voltage. • Compare particles under equal-speed, equal-momentum and equal-energy conditions. • Explain diffraction evidence and distinguish matter-wave wavelength from particle size and phase speed.

Can something detected as an electron also diffract?

A beam of electrons can produce a structured scattering pattern from a crystal, with enhanced detection at some angles and reduced detection at others. Individual arrivals transfer charge locally, yet the overall pattern requires a wave description. De Broglie proposed in 1924 that the relation connecting wavelength and momentum for photons should extend to matter. Symmetry between radiation and matter motivated the proposal; experiment, rather than symmetry alone, establishes its validity.

The de Broglie relationLaTeX
p is momentum magnitude in kg m/s; λ is wavelength in m. The general relation uses the appropriate momentum. p = mv and its substituted expression are nonrelativistic approximations for a massive particle.

Dimensional check: h has units kg m²/s and p has kg m/s, so h/p has units m. For a specified particle in a specified frame, increasing momentum shortens the wavelength. The relation is independent of electric charge. A neutron has matter-wave behaviour although it is electrically neutral. Different particles at equal momentum have equal wavelength; their masses and kinetic energies need not be equal.

What is actually waving?

A matter wave is not an electron repeatedly stretching into a material string, and it is not an ordinary sound wave requiring a medium. In quantum theory a wavefunction supplies amplitudes whose interference determines detection probabilities. The squared magnitude is related to probability density; it is not a literal electric-field oscillation or the electron’s geometric diameter. Matter waves therefore remain relevant to neutral particles as well as charged ones.

An ideal definite-momentum plane wave has a definite wavelength but is spread out. A localised particle state is described by a packet formed from a range of wave components. The packet’s group velocity corresponds to the free particle’s velocity. The phase velocity describes motion of constant phase of a component and must not be identified with a particle signal speed. It can differ from the group speed; its precise expression depends on the dispersion relation and energy convention. These distinctions resolve the temptation to set every wave speed equal to λf and call it the electron speed.

Why a ball’s matter-wave effect is imperceptible

An electron and a familiar ball

Problem
Calculate the wavelengths of an electron moving at 5.4 × 10⁶ m/s and a 0.150 kg ball moving at 30.0 m/s.

  1. 1.For the electron, v/c ≈ 0.018, so p ≈ mₑv = 4.919 × 10⁻²⁴ kg m/s. Hence λ = h/p = 1.347 × 10⁻¹⁰ m = 0.135 nm.
  2. 2.For the ball, p = 0.150 × 30.0 = 4.50 kg m/s and λ = 1.47 × 10⁻³⁴ m.
  3. 3.The electron wavelength is comparable with atomic spacings and can give diffraction from a crystal. The ball wavelength is far smaller than accessible structures; environmental interactions further suppress coherent macroscopic interference.
  4. 4.Small wavelength does not mean the ball has ceased to obey quantum mechanics. Detectable interference also depends on coherence, preparation and apparatus.

At equal speeds a heavier object has larger momentum and shorter wavelength. At equal kinetic energies the mass dependence is different. A phrase such as heavier particles have shorter wavelengths is incomplete unless the held-fixed condition is stated. Molecules and other composite particles can also show interference when prepared coherently; wave behaviour is not restricted by an absolute atomic-size boundary.

A second macroscopic scale check

Problem
A ball of mass 0.12 kg travels at 20 m/s. Estimate its matter wavelength.

  1. 1.At this low speed, p = mv = 0.12 × 20 = 2.40 kg m/s.
  2. 2.λ = h/p = 6.62607 × 10⁻³⁴/2.40 = 2.76 × 10⁻³⁴ m.
  3. 3.This is a wavelength associated with the centre-of-mass momentum, not the diameter of the ball. It is far below scales useful for observing ordinary ball diffraction.

Derivation: wavelength from kinetic energy

For a nonrelativistic massive particle, K = ½mv² and p = mv. Substituting v = p/m into K gives K = ½m(p/m)² = p²/(2m). Multiply by 2m and take the positive root to obtain the momentum magnitude √(2mK). Substitute that result into de Broglie’s relation. This derives a useful consequence of the hypothesis; it does not derive the hypothesis itself.

Kinetic-energy formLaTeX
K is in J and m in kg for SI calculation. Applicable when K ≪ mc². At fixed mass, λ varies as K⁻¹ᐟ²; at equal K, λ varies as m⁻¹ᐟ².

If kinetic energy becomes four times as large for the same particle, momentum doubles and wavelength halves. It does not fall to one quarter. At equal K a proton’s wavelength is about 1/√1836 of an electron’s wavelength, whereas at equal speed the factor would be 1/1836. Always identify the comparison condition.

Derivation: an electron accelerated from rest

For charge magnitude e accelerated through a potential difference magnitude U, the electric field does work eU. If initial kinetic energy and losses are negligible, K = eU. Insert this into the kinetic-energy expression. For a singly charged particle of another mass, use that mass; for charge magnitude |q| use |q|U. A neutral particle cannot be accelerated this way by a uniform electrostatic potential difference.

Electron wavelength from accelerating voltageLaTeX
U is positive accelerating magnitude. The convenient numerical expression applies to an electron starting nearly at rest in the nonrelativistic regime. The denominator is dimensionless; do not insert a value in kV as though it were in V.
Calculated electron wavelength falls as inverse square root of voltageElectron accelerated nearly from restλ (nm)Accelerating voltage U (V)501001502002500.10.20.3λ ∝ 1/√U54 V → 0.167 nm216 V → 0.0834 nm
Electron wavelength versus accelerating voltage— A computed nonrelativistic curve. Wavelength falls with inverse square root of voltage; doubling voltage does not halve wavelength.
A wavelength suitable for crystal diffraction

Problem
Electrons are accelerated from rest through 54 V. Find their wavelength and predict the value at 216 V.

  1. 1.The kinetic energy at 54 V is 54 eV = 8.652 × 10⁻¹⁸ J, far below the electron rest-energy scale of about 511 keV.
  2. 2.λ = h/√(2mₑeU) = 0.1669 nm at 54 V.
  3. 3.Increasing U to 216 V multiplies K by 4 and momentum by 2, so wavelength becomes 0.0834 nm.
  4. 4.Atomic-scale spacings are suitable for observing diffraction of these electrons. An electron wavelength does not tell us that the electron’s physical diameter is 0.167 nm.

For very large accelerating voltage the kinetic-energy equality K = eU remains valid in an ideal electrostatic acceleration, but p² = 2mK no longer holds accurately. The relativistic momentum must then replace √(2mK). Stating the low-speed assumption matters: extending the convenient 1.227/√U expression to arbitrary energies creates systematic errors.

Experimental evidence: a crystal as a wave probe

Davisson and Germer scattered electrons from a nickel crystal and found strong angular variations in detected intensity as beam conditions changed. A heated source supplies electrons, an accelerating potential sets their energy, apertures collimate the beam, and a movable detector samples scattered-electron count versus angle. Repeated crystal spacings allow scattered wave amplitudes to reinforce at selected directions. The electron wavelength inferred from the angular pattern agreed with h/p. This qualitative confirmation is useful evidence for the relation, without requiring a full crystal-diffraction derivation.

Electron diffraction apparatus in schematic plan viewTest wavelength through angular scatteringElectron gunNickel crystalDetector(one angle)Other detector positionsApertures collimate the beam; U controls electron momentum.Count versus angle reveals interference, not a wavy track.
Electron diffraction tests the matter-wave hypothesis— Schematic plan view. A movable detector samples directions from a crystal. The dashed arc indicates possible detector positions, not electron motion.

Diffraction is a collective statistical pattern built from local detection events; drawing a wavy track through the apparatus would imply a classical oscillating trajectory that has not been measured. Changing accelerating voltage changes wavelength and therefore the angular pattern. Keeping voltage fixed but increasing the electron rate makes counts accumulate faster under unchanged coherent conditions; it does not shorten each electron’s de Broglie wavelength.

Check the photon limit and connect the chapter

For a photon, pγ = hf/c. Insert this into λ = h/p: h/(hf/c) = c/f, exactly the vacuum electromagnetic wavelength. Thus the momentum–wavelength relation connects both radiation and matter, but their energy–momentum relations differ. A photon has E = pc; a slow massive particle has kinetic energy K = p²/(2m). Confusing these would lead to incorrect speeds and energies even if the wavelength calculation looked familiar.

Photon consistency checkLaTeX
This is an algebraic consistency check using the photon momentum relationship, not an independent proof of the matter-wave hypothesis.
Predict and resolve

An electron and a neutron have the same de Broglie wavelength. Are their speeds equal? Their momentum magnitudes are equal. At low speed v = p/m, so the lighter electron moves faster. Equal wavelength fixes momentum, not mass or speed.

Quick Quiz

Quiz

Quick check

Which quantity directly fixes de Broglie wavelength?

λ = h/p. Charge can affect how a beam is prepared but does not appear in the relation.

Quick check

For the same slow particle, kinetic energy becomes four times larger. What happens to wavelength?

p = √(2mK), so a factor 4 in K gives a factor 2 in p and a factor 1/2 in λ.

Quick check

An electron and a proton have equal momentum magnitudes. What can be concluded?

The relation λ = h/p gives equal wavelength. Speed and kinetic energy depend on mass for a massive particle.

Quick check

What does electron diffraction demonstrate?

A structured angular distribution reflects interference of amplitudes. It does not measure a wavy classical trajectory.

Quick check

Why is λ = 1.227 nm/√[U/(1 V)] limited at high voltage?

K = eU still represents ideal electrostatic energy gain, but p = √(2mK) must be replaced at relativistic energies.

Practice Problems

Practice Problems
  1. Find the wavelengths of (a) a 0.040 kg bullet at 1.0 km/s, (b) a 0.060 kg ball at 1.0 m/s, and (c) a 1.0 × 10⁻⁹ kg dust particle at 2.2 m/s.
  2. An electron starting nearly at rest is accelerated through 150 V. Find λ and the voltage needed to halve that wavelength.
  3. Compare electron and proton wavelengths at (a) equal speed and (b) equal kinetic energy, using mp/mₑ = 1836 and assuming both are slow.
  4. Derive a useful wavelength formula for a slow charged particle of mass m and charge magnitude |q| accelerated from rest through U. State how the result changes if initial kinetic energy K₀ is not negligible.
  5. Explain why a measured matter wavelength does not identify an electron’s size, and distinguish phase and group velocity.

All speeds are nonrelativistic. Use p = mv then λ = h/p. (a) p = 40 kg m/s, so λ = 1.66 × 10⁻³⁵ m. (b) p = 0.060 kg m/s, so λ = 1.10 × 10⁻³² m. (c) p = 2.2 × 10⁻⁹ kg m/s, so λ = 3.01 × 10⁻²⁵ m. These very short wavelengths explain why ordinary objects do not show readily measurable diffraction; they are not particle diameters.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

• Matter-wave wavelength is λ = h/p and does not depend directly on charge. • Use p ≈ mv and λ = h/√(2mK) only for slow massive particles. • For an electron accelerated from rest, λ ≈ 1.227 nm/√[U/(1 V)] in the nonrelativistic regime. • Comparison statements must specify equal momentum, speed or kinetic energy. • Wavefunction interference predicts detection probabilities; wavelength is not particle diameter. • Crystal diffraction supplies evidence for electron wave behaviour. • Group velocity corresponds to free-particle motion; phase speed is a different concept. • The photon relation p = hf/c makes h/p equal the vacuum light wavelength.

Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.

Loading your progress…