Skip to lesson content

Lesson 2 of 8

Nuclei · Lesson 2 of 8

Nuclear Size and the Nuclear Force

“Connect nuclear radius with nearly constant density, then interpret the short-range nuclear interaction through a schematic potential-energy curve.”

Learning Objectives

• Use the empirical radius law to compare nuclear sizes. • Derive the near independence of nuclear density from mass number. • Explain short range, saturation and approximate charge independence. • Infer attraction or repulsion from a potential-energy slope.

A turning distance is not automatically a nuclear radius

An alpha particle may reverse because of Coulomb repulsion before touching a nucleus. Its turning distance therefore gives an upper bound on the size being probed. More energetic probes approach closer, eventually becoming sensitive to the finite charge distribution and nuclear interactions. Fast-electron scattering provides information about the nuclear charge distribution. Strongly interacting nuclear probes can also be sensitive to the matter distribution. These inferred radii need not be identical, because the probes respond to different distributions.

Many nuclei can be assigned an approximate spherical radius. Real nuclei need not be perfectly spherical, and even a spherical distribution does not have an infinitely sharp surface. The empirical radius law is nevertheless a useful systematic description, especially for medium and heavy nuclei. It should be interpreted as a model of characteristic size rather than as an exact hard boundary of every nuclide.

Empirical nuclear-radius lawLaTeX
A is the dimensionless nucleon count, and R and R₀ must use the same length unit. The law is approximate; very light nuclei and detailed charge/matter radii can deviate.
Nuclear radius scales as the cube root of AA = 8A = 64R = 2R₀R = 4R₀8 times as many nucleons → 8 times the volume → 2 times R.
Nuclear-radius scaling— The two schematic nuclear radii are drawn in the ratio 1 : 2 for mass numbers 8 : 64. This illustrates the empirical scaling, not exact light-nucleus measurements.
Comparing gold and silver nuclei

Problem
Estimate RAu/RAg for mass numbers 197 and 107.

  1. 1.Both estimates use the same R₀, which cancels: RAu/RAg = (197/107)¹ᐟ³.
  2. 2.The cube root gives about 1.23. The gold nucleus has a radius roughly 23% larger, although it has about 84% more nucleons.
  3. 3.The volume ratio is 197/107 ≈ 1.84, illustrating why radius and mass ratios must not be interchanged.

Deriving a nearly constant density

Approximate the nuclear mass as A times a representative nucleon mass m_N ≈ 1.67 × 10⁻²⁷ kg. This ignores the small proton–neutron difference and the percent-level effect of binding. A spherical volume is 4πR³/3. Substituting R = R₀A¹ᐟ³ makes the dependence on A visible before any numbers are inserted.

Volume and densityLaTeX
The factors of A cancel. V is in m³ and ρ in kg/m³ when SI units are used. Nearly constant density follows from the approximate assumptions, not an exact equality of all nuclear density profiles.

With R₀ = 1.2 × 10⁻¹⁵ m, the estimate is ρ ≈ 2.3 × 10¹⁷ kg/m³. A larger nucleus contains more nucleons but also has proportionally more volume. It is not denser simply because its total mass is greater. Ordinary matter has a much lower mean density because most of an atom’s volume lies outside its compact nucleus. This contrast does not mean fields and atomic electrons cease to exist outside the nucleus.

Density of an iron-sized nucleus

Problem
Estimate the density for A = 56 using a nuclear mass of approximately 55.92 u and R₀ = 1.2 fm.

  1. 1.The radius is R = 1.2 × 56¹ᐟ³ fm ≈ 4.59 fm. Therefore V = (4π/3)(1.2 × 10⁻¹⁵)³ × 56 ≈ 4.05 × 10⁻⁴³ m³.
  2. 2.The mass is about 55.92 × 1.66054 × 10⁻²⁷ = 9.29 × 10⁻²⁶ kg. Divide mass by volume to obtain ρ ≈ 2.29 × 10¹⁷ kg/m³.
  3. 3.Using Am_N gives nearly the same result. A mean elemental atomic weight around 55.85 u is not the precise nuclear mass of a single iron-56 nucleus.

Why a new attractive interaction is necessary

Two protons repel electrically, while gravity between nucleons is much too weak to explain nuclear binding. Yet neutrons and protons can form bound nuclei whose binding energies are millions of electron volts. A short-range strong nuclear interaction supplies the necessary attraction at ordinary nuclear separations. This residual nuclear interaction acts between nucleons; it is not an inverse-square force extending unchanged across atomic distances.

Three features matter here. First, the attractive part can dominate proton electric repulsion over nuclear distances. Second, it falls rapidly with separation and becomes very small beyond a few femtometres. Third, the nuclear part is approximately similar for proton–proton, neutron–neutron and proton–neutron pairs after other relevant state properties are accounted for. Proton pairs still have an additional Coulomb repulsion. Approximate charge independence does not assert identical total forces for all pairs.

A short-range attractive well with a repulsive coreV (schematic units)r (fm)0.81.52.53.0minimum near 0.8 fmshort-distancerepulsionattraction beyond minimumForce follows −slope: outward left of the minimum, inward right.A schematic central-potential picture; not a universal measured fit.
Nucleon potential-energy picture— Positive slope means an inward force; negative slope means an outward force. The figure is a schematic central-potential model, not a universal law or measured spin-independent fit.

Read the slope, not just the sign of the potential

Recall that in a one-dimensional radial potential description the radial force component is −dV/dr, with positive radial direction outward. On the left side of a potential minimum, V decreases as separation increases: its slope is negative and the force is outward, resisting further compression. On the right side, V increases toward zero: its slope is positive and the force is inward, tending to bind the pair. At the minimum the slope vanishes. A negative potential value by itself does not determine the force direction.

Radial force from the potentialLaTeX
An outward positive Fᵣ corresponds to repulsion. An inward negative Fᵣ corresponds to attraction. If V is measured in J and r in m, the derivative has units J/m = N. This is a schematic central-force interpretation, not a complete nuclear interaction theory.

A minimum near a separation of order 0.8 fm and a steep repulsive core summarise the introductory picture: nucleons do not collapse into one point. At larger separations the short-range attraction fades. Real nuclear interactions also depend on spin and other details; no simple Coulomb-like universal algebraic force is introduced here.

Short range leads to saturation

A nucleon in the interior interacts strongly mainly with a limited group of nearby nucleons. Adding many nucleons far away does not add equally strong pairwise attraction to that original nucleon. This saturation makes the binding contribution per interior nucleon roughly similar as a sufficiently large nucleus grows. Surface nucleons have fewer neighbours, so a small nucleus has a larger fraction of less fully surrounded nucleons. The binding-energy curve will connect this local-interaction picture with stability and energy release.

Predict, then resolve

If A increases by a factor of eight, radius grows by a factor of two and volume by eight. In the simple model, nuclear density remains nearly unchanged. This conclusion concerns nuclear matter; it does not imply that the densities of the corresponding solids or gases must be equal.

Quick Quiz

Quiz

Quick check

If A increases by a factor of eight, what does R do in the radius law?

R is proportional to A¹ᐟ³; the cube root of eight is two.

Quick check

Why does the approximate nuclear density not depend on A?

Using mass ≈ Am_N and volume proportional to R³ proportional to A makes A cancel.

Quick check

If V rises with increasing separation just to the right of its minimum, what is the radial force?

The derivative is positive, so Fᵣ = −dV/dr is negative in an outward-positive coordinate.

Quick check

What does nuclear-force saturation mean?

The short interaction range limits the strong contributions from distant added nucleons.

Quick check

Why can charge and matter radii differ slightly?

Electron scattering is sensitive to charge distribution, while nuclear probes can also probe the matter distribution and strong interaction.

Practice Problems

Practice Problems
  1. Use R₀ = 1.2 fm to estimate radii at A = 27 and A = 216. Compare their volumes and densities in the simple model.
  2. Derive the density law from R = R₀A¹ᐟ³ and estimate it with m_N = 1.67 × 10⁻²⁷ kg.
  3. Estimate the ratio of the radii of gold-197 and silver-107 and explain why 197/107 is not the radius ratio.
  4. A schematic potential has negative slope at r₁ and positive slope at r₂. Determine force directions and explain why both potentials could still be negative.
  5. Explain why “the nuclear force is charge independent” does not mean two protons experience exactly the same total interaction as two neutrons in every state.

The cube roots are 3 and 6, so the radii are 3.6 fm and 7.2 fm. The radius ratio is two, the volume ratio is eight and the nucleon/mass ratio is eight. Since both mass and volume increase by the same factor, the approximate densities are equal.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

• The empirical radius law is R = R₀A¹ᐟ³, with R₀ about 1.2 fm. • A Coulomb turning point can lie outside the nuclear distribution. • Mass and volume both scale approximately with A, giving near-constant nuclear density. • The density estimate is about 2.3 × 10¹⁷ kg/m³. • Nuclear attraction is strong at nuclear distances but short-ranged. • A steep short-distance repulsive core prevents unlimited compression in the schematic picture. • Force direction follows the negative potential slope, not the sign of V alone. • Saturation reflects the limited set of nearby strongly interacting neighbours.

Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.

Loading your progress…