Skip to lesson content

Lesson 3 of 8

Nuclei · Lesson 3 of 8

Mass–Energy and Nuclear Binding

“Explain why binding lowers a system’s mass, calculate binding energy from consistent atomic or nuclear masses, and distinguish total binding from binding per nucleon.”

Learning Objectives

• Relate rest mass and rest energy without implying complete conversion in ordinary reactions. • Calculate nuclear mass defect using consistent mass conventions. • Distinguish mass in u or MeV/c² from energy in MeV. • Interpret positive binding energy and binding energy per nucleon.

Energy belongs to the entire physical system

Imagine assembling separated protons and neutrons into a bound nucleus. If energy escapes into radiation or particle motion, the final nucleus left at rest has less energy than the separated resting constituents had. Its mass is correspondingly smaller. No nucleons need disappear. A composite system’s rest mass includes the energy of its internal motion and interactions; adding isolated-particle rest masses does not automatically give the bound system’s mass.

Rest-energy equivalenceLaTeX
m is the invariant/rest mass of the system and c is the speed of light in vacuum. In SI, kg × m²/s² gives joules. A moving system also has kinetic energy; this expression alone is not its full laboratory energy.

Total energy, including rest energy, is conserved. The sum of the rest masses of separate reacting objects need not stay constant, because their internal binding changes and energy can move into other forms. This is not a loophole in energy conservation. For a bound nucleus the rest energy remains positive, but is lower than the sum of its separated constituents’ rest energies.

The rest-energy equivalent of one gram

Problem
Calculate the rest-energy equivalent of 1.0 g. Does an ordinary nuclear reaction necessarily release all of it?

  1. 1.Convert mass into SI: 1.0 g = 1.0 × 10⁻³ kg. With c ≈ 3.00 × 10⁸ m/s, mc² = 1.0 × 10⁻³ × 9.00 × 10¹⁶ = 9.0 × 10¹³ J.
  2. 2.This is the rest-energy equivalent of the entire gram, not automatically the energy available from a particular fuel reaction.
  3. 3.Ordinary fission or fusion changes only a small fraction of the total rest mass. Available energy must be computed from the initial-minus-final system masses.

Mass defect measures the difference from free nucleons

Definition
Nuclear mass defect Δm

The sum of the rest masses of the separated protons and neutrons minus the rest mass of their bound nucleus. For a bound state relative to complete nucleon separation, this difference is positive.

Mass defect using nuclear massesLaTeX
Use bare proton mass mₚ, neutron mass mₙ and nuclear mass M_nucleus consistently. B is the positive energy required to separate the nucleus completely into resting free nucleons. A single free proton has no nuclear binding to separate.
Positive binding energy means a lower bound-system massSeparated, resting nucleonsBound nucleus at restB releasedon bindingSeparating all nucleons requires the same positive energy B.The bound system has lower rest energy by B = Δmc².
Mass defect and energy transfer— The vertical separation represents an energy difference B, not a negative total rest mass. Reverse arrows distinguish assembly energy release from separation energy input.

Energy released in assembly and energy needed for complete separation have the same magnitude when initial and final states are reversed. A lower mass does not mean some required neutron or proton is missing: the composition is still Z protons and A − Z neutrons. It is the energy of that configuration that differs. This is why mass number and measured mass must be kept separate.

Why neutral atomic masses need hydrogen-atom masses

Many mass tables give the mass of a neutral atom rather than a bare nucleus. The atom contains Z electrons. If bare proton masses are used while the table’s atom mass is subtracted directly, the electronic rest masses have been included on only one side. This gives a systematic error. Either remove the atomic electrons consistently or replace each free proton by a neutral hydrogen-1 atom in the bookkeeping.

Electron-mass cancellationLaTeX
These approximations neglect electronic binding energies divided by c². Their effect is small for the introductory nuclear calculations here, but not zero in precision mass work.

Substitute M_nucleus ≈ M_atom − Zmₑ into the nuclear mass defect. Then Δm ≈ Zmₚ + Nmₙ − M_atom + Zmₑ. Group the two positive Z terms as Z(mₚ + mₑ), and replace that bracket approximately by m_H. The electron rest masses now cancel in a consistent comparison.

Mass defect using neutral atomic massesLaTeX
m_H is the neutral hydrogen-1 atom mass, not the bare proton mass. Electronic binding-energy corrections are neglected. Use masses from the same convention and sufficient precision before taking a small difference.

Converting a mass difference into energy

The energy equivalent of 1 u follows from the definition of u and c. Multiplying 1.66054 × 10⁻²⁷ kg by (2.9979 × 10⁸ m/s)² gives about 1.4924 × 10⁻¹⁰ J. Divide by 1.602 × 10⁻¹³ J/MeV to obtain about 931.5 MeV. The factor c² has already been used in this conversion.

Compatible mass and energy unitsLaTeX
The first equality expresses energy; the second expresses mass. If Δm = x u, then B ≈ x × 931.5 MeV. Do not multiply this energy by c² a second time.
An oxygen binding calculation

Problem
Use the rounded values mₚ = 1.00727 u, mₙ = 1.00866 u, mₑ = 0.00055 u and oxygen-16 atomic mass 15.99493 u to calculate its binding.

  1. 1.Oxygen-16 has 8 protons and 8 neutrons. Its nuclear mass is approximately 15.99493 − 8(0.00055) = 15.99053 u.
  2. 2.The free-nucleon mass sum is 8(1.00727) + 8(1.00866) = 16.12744 u. Therefore Δm = 16.12744 − 15.99053 = 0.13691 u.
  3. 3.The mass difference can also be written as about 127.53 MeV/c². Its energy equivalent, the binding energy, is B = 0.13691 × 931.5 = 127.53 MeV.
  4. 4.Mass has units MeV/c² and energy has units MeV. The last answer is an energy, and the rounded input masses limit its precision.
A nitrogen binding calculation

Problem
Find B for nitrogen-14 from neutral atomic masses m_H = 1.007825 u, mₙ = 1.008665 u and M_atom = 14.00307 u.

  1. 1.Nitrogen has Z = 7 and N = 7. With atomic masses, use hydrogen-atom mass to obtain Δm = 7(1.007825) + 7(1.008665) − 14.00307.
  2. 2.The result is Δm = 0.112360 u. Thus B = 0.112360 × 931.5 = 104.66 MeV ≈ 104.7 MeV.
  3. 3.The positive binding energy says complete separation requires energy. It does not say the nucleus has positive energy relative to its separated nucleons: its bound-system energy is lower.

Total binding and binding per nucleon answer different questions

Binding energy per nucleonLaTeX
B is the total nuclear binding energy and A is the nucleon count. B/A is usually quoted as MeV per nucleon. It is an average, not necessarily the energy needed to remove one specified last nucleon.

For the nitrogen calculation, B/A = 104.66/14 ≈ 7.48 MeV per nucleon. For the rounded oxygen calculation it is 127.53/16 ≈ 7.97 MeV per nucleon. A larger nucleus can have a larger total B while having a smaller B/A than a smaller nucleus. Compare the intended quantity, and use the complete total binding energies when evaluating a reaction.

A subtraction needs enough precision

Replacing every isotope mass by its integer mass number before subtracting can erase much of the mass defect. Keep the supplied precision through the subtraction and round the final energy. A small mass difference is physically important because c² is large.

Quick Quiz

Quiz

Quick check

A bound nucleus has lower mass than its free nucleons. What accounts for the difference?

The same constituent counts can form a lower-energy system. The energy difference divided by c² appears as the mass defect.

Quick check

Which mass should accompany neutral atomic masses in the binding formula?

Hydrogen-atom masses cancel the atomic electron rest masses approximately, with electronic binding corrections neglected.

Quick check

If Δm = 0.100 u, what is B?

The energy conversion is 1 u c² ≈ 931.5 MeV. Multiplying the numerical mass in u by 931.5 gives energy in MeV.

Quick check

A nucleus has B = 160 MeV and A = 20. What is B/A?

Divide total binding by the number of nucleons: 160/20 = 8.

Quick check

Does mc² for an entire fuel sample equal the energy necessarily released by an ordinary reaction?

The products retain almost all the original rest mass. Reaction energy is a difference between complete initial and final systems.

Practice Problems

Practice Problems
  1. Calculate the energy equivalent of a 0.00200 u mass defect in MeV and joules. Use 1 MeV = 1.602 × 10⁻¹³ J.
  2. Derive the neutral-atomic-mass binding expression from the nuclear-mass one, stating the neglected correction.
  3. Find total B and B/A for nitrogen-14 using m_H = 1.007825 u, mₙ = 1.008665 u and M_atom = 14.00307 u.
  4. A hypothetical nucleus with A = 40 has B/A = 8.5 MeV per nucleon. Find B and Δm in u. Does B/A give the exact energy to remove its last neutron?
  5. A student inserts a neutral atom mass into Zmₚ + Nmₙ − M and obtains too small a binding. Explain the error and estimate its scale for Z = 8 using mₑ = 0.00054858 u.

B = 0.00200 × 931.5 = 1.863 MeV. Convert to joules: 1.863 × 1.602 × 10⁻¹³ = 2.98 × 10⁻¹³ J. The mass defect itself may be expressed as 1.863 MeV/c², but the binding energy has no remaining c² denominator.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

• Rest energy contributes to the mass of an entire composite system. • A bound nucleus has lower rest energy than its separated resting nucleons. • Mass defect is positive for binding relative to complete free-nucleon separation. • Binding energy B = Δmc² is positive separation energy. • Neutral atomic masses require consistent electron bookkeeping, usually through hydrogen-atom masses. • 1 u c² ≈ 931.5 MeV, while 1 u ≈ 931.5 MeV/c². • Total binding B and average binding B/A must be labelled separately. • A positive binding average is not a complete prediction of every individual separation energy.

Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.

Loading your progress…