Skip to lesson content

Lesson 7 of 8

Nuclei · Lesson 7 of 8

Fusion and Stellar Energy

“Explain fusion through binding, the Coulomb barrier and quantum tunnelling, then follow the proton–proton cycle and estimate ideal fusion energy.”

Learning Objectives

• Distinguish a fusion Q-value from the Coulomb barrier to close approach. • Estimate a contact barrier and interpret a classical temperature estimate. • Track charge, nucleons and energy through the proton–proton cycle. • Explain why total fusion energy and usable heat need not be identical.

Light nuclei can become more tightly bound together

Fusion combines light nuclei into a nuclear system with different binding. Many suitable light-nucleus channels have lower total final rest mass, giving a positive Q-value. This is the light side of the same binding-energy curve that explains heavy-nucleus fission. It does not say that every possible combination releases energy: a specified channel must still be tested with masses and conservation laws.

Two deuterium-fusion branchesLaTeX
These are two different possible branches, not two compulsory stages of one event. Each conserves A = 4 and total charge +2e. The quoted energies are approximate Q-values.

A deuteron is a hydrogen-2 nucleus, containing one proton and one neutron. In the first branch, one helium-3 nucleus and a neutron emerge; in the second, a tritium nucleus and a proton emerge. The products have different rest masses, so the released energies differ. Counting incoming nuclei is essential for a bulk calculation: each event consumes two deuterons, not one.

Positive Q does not remove the repulsive barrier

Far outside each nucleus, positively charged reactants repel electrically. To experience substantial short-range nuclear attraction, they must approach to femtometre separations. A classical contact estimate compares their Coulomb potential energy with their incoming relative kinetic energy. This barrier concerns the route toward interaction; Q concerns the complete initial and final states. A reaction can have positive Q while still being difficult to initiate.

Coulomb contact-energy estimateLaTeX
R₁ + R₂ is the assumed centre separation when spherical nuclei touch. This is a simple classical Coulomb estimate, not a complete quantum fusion threshold or a precise nuclear potential.
A Coulomb barrier is different from reaction QCoulomb potential energy (keV)Centre separation r (fm)Contact model: r = 4 fmU = 360 keV481216200100200300400Two deuterons of assumed radius 2 fm each; nuclear attraction omitted.
Contact barrier for deuterons— The example assumes a radius of 2.0 fm for each deuteron, so centre separation at contact is 4.0 fm. The actual quantum problem has tunnelling and is not a hard-sphere collision.
Estimating a deuteron contact barrier

Problem
Two deuterons each have assumed radius 2.0 fm and charge +e. Estimate their Coulomb energy at contact.

  1. 1.Use centre separation R₁ + R₂ = 4.0 fm, not the radius 2.0 fm of one nucleus.
  2. 2.U_C = 1.440 MeV fm / 4.0 fm = 0.360 MeV = 360 keV. This is a positive repulsive energy.
  3. 3.It is distinct from the 3.27 MeV or 4.03 MeV reaction Q-values. Quantum tunnelling also means fusion probability is not a strict classical step from zero to certainty at this energy.

Why the Sun does not need every proton above the barrier

For a classical ideal gas, the mean translational kinetic energy per particle is 3k_BT/2. Equating this to an illustrative 400 keV proton barrier gives a temperature around 3 × 10⁹ K. This is a classical comparison, not the Sun’s actual ignition requirement. At a solar-core temperature near 1.5 × 10⁷ K, k_BT is only about 1.3 keV. The source of solar fusion cannot be explained adequately by claiming that protons simply all climb a 400 keV barrier.

A classical thermal comparisonLaTeX
With K = 400 keV and k_B = 1.381 × 10⁻²³ J/K, this gives about 3.1 × 10⁹ K. K must be converted to joules. This comparison is not a hard quantum threshold for fusion.

Quantum tunnelling gives a finite probability of penetrating the repulsive barrier at energies below its classical height. Within a thermal distribution, somewhat faster-than-average particles contribute more strongly because penetration probability increases with energy, while very energetic particles become scarcer. The interplay matters. In proton–proton fusion a weak transformation is also required, contributing to the slow rate. Tunnelling allows close approach; it does not violate total energy conservation or change a channel’s Q-value.

The proton–proton cycle builds helium in stages

The first two nuclear stagesLaTeX
The first step converts one proton into a neutron inside the new deuteron through a weak process. A neutrino carries some of the released energy away. The two listed stages must each occur twice to produce two helium-3 nuclei.
The final helium-building stageLaTeX
Six input nucleons become four in helium-4 plus two returned protons. Charge balances as 2 + 2 = 2 + 1 + 1. The returned protons reduce the net proton consumption.
The proton–proton chain builds helium in stagesp + p → D + e⁺ + νₑthen D + p → ³He + γp + p → D + e⁺ + νₑthen D + p → ³He + γ³He + ³He → ⁴He + p + pTwo protons return to the initial pool.Two positrons later annihilate with two electrons.Net: four H atoms → one He atom + energy carried away.
Two branches feeding helium formation— Two copies of the first stages produce the two helium-3 nuclei. The positrons subsequently annihilate with electrons; the diagram records the particle flow, not real spatial trajectories.

A positron has the electron’s mass and opposite charge. When a slow positron annihilates with an electron, their combined rest-energy equivalent is about 1.022 MeV, carried predominantly by two photons in the simple at-rest process. There are two positrons per completed displayed cycle, so the annihilation contribution must be counted twice if the initial bookkeeping includes the consumed electrons.

Adding a whole displayed cycle

Problem
Using the rounded stage energies, find the total including two positron–electron annihilations.

  1. 1.The two weak proton–proton steps contribute 2 × 0.42 MeV; the two deuteron-capture steps contribute 2 × 5.49 MeV; the helium-3 combination contributes 12.86 MeV.
  2. 2.Add two annihilations: 2 × 1.02 MeV. The sum is 0.84 + 10.98 + 12.86 + 2.04 = 26.72 MeV, conventionally rounded to about 26.7 MeV.
  3. 3.The net nuclear/electron bookkeeping consumes four protons and two electrons and forms one helium-4 nucleus plus two neutrinos and released energy. Equivalently, four neutral hydrogen atoms become one neutral helium atom when the unchanged electron accounting is included.
  4. 4.The neutrinos carry away part of the total energy. The heat deposited in the star is less than the full 26.7 MeV, and the initially emitted photons are repeatedly reprocessed before energy emerges from the stellar surface.

Stellar evolution and the limits of energy-producing fusion

Hydrogen burning through fusion supplies the Sun during its main-sequence stage. As core fuel is used, the balance of pressure and gravity changes; contraction can heat later fuel stages and the outer layers can expand toward a red-giant phase. Helium fusion can make carbon at higher temperatures, and sufficiently massive stars can progress to heavier fuels. Different stellar masses have different histories; not every star fuses its way through every element.

Steady energy-producing fusion does not continue indefinitely beyond the strongly bound iron-group region. Forming still heavier species can require energy or other processes, including neutron captures and explosive environments. This statement is about net energy generation, not an absolute ban on any reaction producing a heavier nucleus. The binding curve provides the physical reason to expect a change in the energetics.

Controlled fusion needs confinement as well as temperature

At high temperatures a fusion fuel is a plasma of nuclei and electrons. Research systems seek enough reaction rate for long enough while keeping energy losses under control. Raising temperature alone does not establish useful output: density, confinement, reaction probability and the energy invested all matter. Magnetic and inertial approaches are ways of addressing confinement. A positive microscopic Q-value is not a guarantee of a practical power source or unlimited fuel.

An ideal deuterium energy reservoir

Problem
Suppose every deuteron in 2.0 kg of pure deuterium reacts through the 3.27 MeV branch, with no losses. Estimate how long the released energy could power a 100 W lamp.

  1. 1.Using molar mass 2.014102 g/mol, the number of deuterium nuclei is (2000/2.014102)(6.022 × 10²³) ≈ 5.98 × 10²⁶.
  2. 2.Each reaction consumes two nuclei, so the number of events is about 2.99 × 10²⁶. Multiplying by 3.27 MeV gives about 9.78 × 10²⁶ MeV = 1.57 × 10¹⁴ J.
  3. 3.At 100 J/s, t = E/P ≈ 1.57 × 10¹² s, or about 4.96 × 10⁴ years using 3.154 × 10⁷ s per year.
  4. 4.This is an ideal energy-accounting upper estimate using a specified branch and complete usable conversion. It is not a claim that an actual fusion system can deliver that lamp output without losses or engineering requirements.

Quick Quiz

Quiz

Quick check

Why can a fusion channel have positive Q yet be difficult to initiate?

The barrier concerns approach to short-range nuclear interaction; Q compares complete initial and final masses.

Quick check

Two deuterons each have radius 2 fm. What centre separation belongs in the simple contact estimate?

The distance between centres at contact is the sum of the two radii.

Quick check

What essential quantum effect helps explain sub-barrier solar fusion?

Quantum penetration can occur below a classical barrier; thermal distributions and weak reaction rates also affect the total rate.

Quick check

How many net protons are consumed by the displayed completed proton–proton cycle?

Two helium-3 nuclei are built using six proton inputs, but the final stage returns two protons, leaving four net consumed.

Quick check

Does all of the approximately 26.7 MeV remain as heat in the star?

The total release includes energy carried by neutrinos, so the locally deposited heat is smaller.

Practice Problems

Practice Problems
  1. Balance the charge and nucleon counts for both deuterium-fusion branches: helium-3 + neutron, and tritium + proton. Explain why the quoted Q-values need not match.
  2. Estimate the Coulomb contact barrier of two deuterons of radius 2.0 fm each. Use ke² = 1.440 MeV fm. Compare the answer with a 3.27 MeV reaction Q.
  3. Use 3k_BT/2 = 400 keV to find a classical temperature estimate. Why does the result not imply that fusion at 1.5 × 10⁷ K is impossible?
  4. Explain the factors of two in the approximately 26.7 MeV proton–proton-cycle accounting, including annihilation.
  5. For complete reaction of 2.0 kg of pure deuterium through the 3.27 MeV branch, estimate event count and the ideal time for a 100 W lamp. Use molar mass 2.014102 g/mol.

The two input deuterons have A = 4 and Z = 2. Helium-3 plus a neutron gives A = 3 + 1 and Z = 2 + 0. Tritium plus a proton gives A = 3 + 1 and Z = 1 + 1. Both balance counts, but their product masses and bindings differ, so their Q-values are about 3.27 and 4.03 MeV rather than one shared value.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

• Fusion energy comes from the rest-mass difference of a specified complete reaction. • A positive Q-value is distinct from the Coulomb barrier to close approach. • A contact estimate uses the sum of nuclear radii. • Solar fusion requires quantum tunnelling as well as thermal and interaction-rate reasoning. • The displayed proton–proton cycle consumes four protons net and forms helium-4. • Positron annihilation contributes to consistent full-cycle energy accounting. • The total release of about 26.7 MeV includes energy carried away by neutrinos. • A deuterium–deuterium event consumes two deuterons. • Controlled fusion requires confinement and energy-loss management, not temperature alone.

Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.

Loading your progress…