Atoms · Lesson 1 of 7
Rutherford Scattering and the Nuclear Atom
“Use alpha-particle scattering to infer a compact nucleus, analyse closest approach, and distinguish evidence from model assumptions.”
• Connect atomic neutrality with the need for positive charge. • Explain how the scattering apparatus measures particle directions. • Infer nuclear size and charge concentration from the observations. • Calculate a head-on distance of closest approach and state its limitations.
How can an invisible structure be tested?
An atom is far too small to inspect with an ordinary optical microscope. Yet an object can reveal its structure by changing the motion of a probe. If almost every probe passes through while a few reverse direction, the rare events matter: a model must explain the entire distribution, not only its average. Rutherford scattering is an example of reconstructing a microscopic structure from measurable outcomes.
Discharge experiments established that atoms contain electrons, with charge −e. Since an ordinary atom is neutral, it must also contain an equal amount of positive charge. Neutrality specifies a total charge; it does not specify where that charge is located. Thomson pictured electrons embedded in a diffuse positively charged sphere. Rutherford instead concentrated the positive charge and most of the mass in a very small nucleus. Both pictures describe roughly the same overall atomic size, about 10⁻¹⁰ m; the new feature is the much smaller concentration inside it.
| Question | Thomson picture | Nuclear picture |
|---|---|---|
| Where is positive charge? | Spread through the atom | Concentrated in the nucleus |
| Where is most mass? | Distributed with the positive background | Concentrated in the nucleus |
| Where are electrons? | Embedded in the background | Outside the nucleus |
| Can one encounter readily reverse a heavy α particle? | Diffuse forces make this very unlikely | A close nuclear encounter can do so |
The experiment: apparatus, variables and observations
An α particle is a helium nucleus: its charge is +2e and its mass is about four proton masses. A radioactive source supplies energetic particles; lead apertures select a narrow beam. A very thin gold foil is the target. A zinc sulphide screen gives a tiny flash when a particle strikes it, and a microscope allows these scintillations to be counted. Moving the detector around the foil measures counts at different angles from the original beam direction. A vacuum reduces unwanted scattering by air.
For the source arrangement, a foil thickness near 2.1 × 10⁻⁷ m and particles with energy of several MeV were used. Most particles emerged in or close to the incident direction. A small fraction scattered substantially, and about one in 8000 was reported beyond 90° for that arrangement. Such fractions depend on energy, thickness and detector geometry; they are not universal atomic constants. Repeated small changes in a diffuse background could not explain the observed frequency of very large single deflections.
The inference is that most of the atomic volume contains no dense concentration of mass or positive charge, while a very small region can exert a strong force. A positive α particle approaching a positive nucleus experiences repulsion. Atomic electrons are too light to reverse a fast heavy α particle in a single elastic encounter. Quantitative scattering agrees with a compact positive charge. The experiment establishes a nuclear structure; it does not directly photograph electrons moving on circular paths.
Read the graph carefully. Large deflections are rare, but their nonzero counts are decisive. The graph compares equal detector solid angles: a larger detector opening collects more particles even at the same angle. The curve is a model trend; a real test also needs backgrounds, detector acceptance and counting uncertainty. Thin foils reduce multiple scattering, so one strong nuclear encounter can be the useful approximation.
Impact parameter is an initial offset
The perpendicular distance from the nuclear centre to the straight line along which an incoming particle would initially travel if it were not deflected.
For fixed incident energy and target charge, a small impact parameter brings the incoming path into a stronger interaction and generally gives a larger deflection. A large impact parameter gives a smaller deflection. The scattering angle θ is measured between incoming and outgoing velocity directions. In the heavy-target idealisation, b = 0 is a head-on encounter and the particle reverses through 180°. This does not require physical contact. The impact parameter is not the distance of closest approach, because the path bends before its turning region.
Deriving the head-on turning distance
Choose zero electrostatic potential energy at infinite separation. For two positive charges the potential energy U = 2kZe²/r is positive. Let an incoming α particle have kinetic energy K far away. Neglect the heavy target’s recoil and any energy loss. In a head-on approach the particle slows, reaches zero speed momentarily, then moves away. Conservation of mechanical energy makes the initial kinetic energy equal to the potential energy at the turning point d.
At fixed target charge, doubling K halves d: a more energetic probe approaches closer. At fixed K, doubling Z doubles d: stronger repulsion turns the probe sooner. For nonzero impact parameter, angular momentum is nonzero and the particle retains tangential speed at closest approach. Setting its entire kinetic energy to zero would then be wrong. A Coulomb turning point outside a nucleus gives an upper size bound, not a measurement of its surface radius.
Problem
Find the head-on turning distance for a 7.7 MeV α particle approaching gold, Z = 79.
- 1.Use energy conservation for an approximately stationary heavy nucleus. Convert K = 7.7 × 10⁶ × 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ = 1.234 × 10⁻¹² J.
- 2.The useful energy-length constant is ke² ≈ 1.440 MeV fm. Thus d = 2 × 79 × 1.440 / 7.7 fm = 29.5 fm = 2.95 × 10⁻¹⁴ m.
- 3.This is much larger than the roughly several-femtometre radius of a gold nucleus. The α particle reverses before contact. Rounding constants more coarsely gives about 30 fm, with the same interpretation.
Problem
If an atomic radius is 10⁻¹⁰ m and a nuclear radius is 10⁻¹⁵ m, what orbital radius would the same ratio give around a Sun of radius 7 × 10⁸ m?
- 1.The radius ratio is 10⁵. Multiplying gives 7 × 10¹³ m.
- 2.Compared with 1.5 × 10¹¹ m, this is about 467 times larger. The analogy communicates relative scale, not the physical nature of an electron state.
- 3.The volume ratio of these ideal spheres is (10⁻⁵)³ = 10⁻¹⁵. Empty space here means absence of dense nuclear matter, not absence of fields or an electron probability distribution.
Changing the target changes the mechanics
Replacing gold by hydrogen changes both charge and mass. A proton has Z = 1, so the repulsion is weaker, and it is lighter than the α particle, so recoil cannot be ignored. In a one-dimensional elastic head-on encounter, conservation of momentum and kinetic energy give the α particle’s final velocity as (mα − mp)/(mα + mp) times its initial velocity. With mα ≈ 4mp, it is +3/5 of the initial velocity: the α particle continues forward while the proton recoils. The fixed-gold backscattering argument cannot simply be transferred to a hydrogen target.
If the foil is made much thicker, can the simple single-scattering interpretation be retained? No. Multiple encounters and energy loss become more important. A thicker foil may increase counts while making the underlying one-nucleus inference harder.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
Which observation most strongly challenges a diffuse positive-charge model?
A rare large reversal requires a very strong local interaction. A diffuse positive charge cannot reproduce that large-angle distribution at the observed rate.
For a fixed heavy target and energy, a smaller impact parameter generally gives what?
A smaller incoming offset leads to a closer strong Coulomb encounter; the head-on limit reverses the trajectory.
Doubling the incident energy in the head-on heavy-target model changes d to what?
The turning distance d = 2kZe²/K is inversely proportional to K when Z is fixed.
Why does a 30 fm turning point not establish a 30 fm nuclear radius?
Conservation of energy locates an electrostatic turning point. Contact with the charge distribution is not required.
Why is treating a hydrogen target as stationary unreliable?
A proton is lighter than an α particle. Both particles must be included in the momentum and energy balance.
Practice Problems
- A detector counts 16 backward events out of 128000 incident particles. Find the fraction and percentage. Explain what a rare event can establish.
- Calculate d for a 5.0 MeV α particle and gold with Z = 79. Use ke² = 1.440 MeV fm.
- At the same incident energy compare the head-on turning distances for silver, Z = 47, and gold, Z = 79.
- Explain why b and the closest distance are different, and why an oblique particle need not stop at closest approach.
- Use masses 4m and m to find the final velocity of an α particle in a head-on elastic collision with an initially stationary proton.
Divide 16 by 128000 to obtain 1.25 × 10⁻⁴, or 0.0125%, equivalent to one in 8000. Rarity does not make an event irrelevant: large deflections require a model with a strong local interaction. This fraction alone is not a universal measure of nuclear radius.
Key Takeaways
• Atomic neutrality fixes the total positive charge, not its spatial distribution. • Most α particles travel nearly straight, while rare large deflections reveal a compact positive nucleus. • A scattering experiment tests a structure through particle counts and angles. • Impact parameter is an incoming offset; it is not closest approach. • For a head-on heavy-target encounter, d = 2kZe²/K. • A Coulomb turning point can lie well outside a nucleus. • Light targets require recoil to be included.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…
Previous
Start of chapter
Next · Lesson 2
Coulomb Orbits and the Classical Atom