Atoms · Lesson 7 of 7
Chapter Summary and Practice
“Connect scattering evidence, atomic models, quantised energies and spectra through an integrated reference and mixed reasoning problems.”
• Choose the appropriate model for scattering, circular motion or a radiative transition. • Connect Bohr radius, speed, energy and spectral predictions. • Check energy signs, units, assumptions and limiting behaviour. • Solve integrated atomic-physics problems and identify model limitations.
One connected argument from evidence to energy
This chapter begins with two sets of observations that a single classical picture cannot explain. Scattering says that an atom contains a compact positive nucleus, with most of its volume outside the dense nucleus. Stable matter and sharp spectral lines say that a continuously radiating classical orbit is inadequate. Bohr retained the nucleus, restricted the allowed states, and connected radiation to differences between their energies. The wave-closure argument motivates the integer condition, while modern quantum mechanics replaces the circular trajectory with a state and a probability description.
| Stage | Evidence or principle | Result | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Charge arrangement | Atomic neutrality and α scattering | Compact positive nucleus; electrons outside it | No direct measurement of circular electron paths |
| Classical mechanics | Coulomb attraction supplies centripetal force | K = −E and U = 2E for a circular orbit | Classical radiation still predicts collapse |
| Bohr restriction | Nonradiating states and L = nħ | Discrete r, v and E | A semiclassical one-electron model |
| Radiative transitions | Energy conservation and photon energy | hν equals a level difference | Line intensity needs more information |
| Wave description | Periodic phase closure | Integer wavelengths motivate quantisation | An orbital is not the circular loop |
A reference that includes conditions
| Relationship | Meaning and symbols | Units | Conditions and limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| F = 2kZe²/r² | Repulsive α–nucleus force; r is separation | N; r in m; e in C | Outside a compact nuclear charge distribution |
| d = 2kZe²/K | Head-on Coulomb turning distance | m when K is J | Heavy fixed target; negligible energy losses; not a contact radius |
| mₑv²/r = ke²/r² | Electric attraction supplies centripetal acceleration | Force in N | Hydrogen; circular motion; approximately fixed proton |
| K = ke²/(2r); U = −ke²/r; E = −ke²/(2r) | Kinetic, potential and total energies | J in SI | U zero at infinity; circular attractive Coulomb model |
| mₑvₙrₙ = nħ | Allowed Bohr angular momentum | J s or kg m²/s | Positive integer n; not the exact modern angular-momentum rule |
| rₙ = a₀n²; a₀ = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m | Allowed hydrogen radius | m | Fixed-proton nonrelativistic Bohr model |
| vₙ = v₁/n; v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s | Hydrogen orbital speed | m/s | Same circular model |
| Tₙ = 2πrₙ/vₙ = T₁n³ | Revolution period; T₁ ≈ 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s | s | Orbital period, not photon period |
| Eₙ = −13.6/n² eV | Leading bound-state energy | eV; multiply by 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ for J | Hydrogen, chosen zero at the ionisation threshold |
| Iₙ = −Eₙ | Positive ionisation energy | eV or J consistently | Minimum energy from the specified initial state |
| hν = |Ef − Ei|; λ = hc/|Ef − Ei| | Photon energy, frequency and vacuum wavelength | J, Hz, m; or hc ≈ 1240 eV nm | A specified radiative transition with a positive gap |
| λmatter = h/p; 2πr = nλmatter | Momentum wavelength and historical loop closure | m; p in kg m/s | Circular-wave motivation; not a complete atomic wavefunction |
The same letter can occur in different contexts. In scattering, K means the incident α-particle kinetic energy. In the bound-orbit calculation, K means electron kinetic energy. In photon calculations, ν is the radiation frequency; f_rev means revolution frequency. State the physical object and process before choosing a relationship. At a numerical step, an energy in eV must be converted to joules before combining with h in J s.
The derivations form a chain
For scattering, the chain is energy conservation → zero speed in the head-on fixed-target limit → K = 2kZe²/d. For hydrogen, the chain is electric force → circular acceleration → K, U and E → angular-momentum quantisation → allowed radius → allowed energy. For spectra, the chain is initial and final atomic states → positive energy gap → hν → wavelength. Mixing these chains is a common source of errors, such as treating a turning point as a nuclear surface or inserting a revolution frequency into a photon calculation.
Check a result before trusting it
A radius and a speed magnitude must be positive. A bound hydrogen total energy must be negative with this zero. A photon energy and wavelength must be positive. An excitation raises total energy, whereas emission lowers it. A higher principal level has a larger Bohr radius, smaller speed, longer revolution period and less negative total energy. These checks often reveal a sign or exponent error before detailed arithmetic does.
A graph should also obey the physical relation. Nuclear-scattering counts decrease strongly toward large deflections for a fixed acceptance, while upper bound-state energies crowd toward zero. An orbit-radius drawing and an energy-level diagram must not be read with the same scale. In a spectrum, greater photon energy means shorter wavelength, so a larger downward arrow belongs to a line farther toward the short-wavelength end.
Problem
A hydrogen atom is at E = −0.85 eV. Find its Bohr radius, ionisation energy, and the wavelength for a direct transition to n = 2.
- 1.Use −13.6/n² = −0.85. Thus n² = 16 and the positive integer is n = 4.
- 2.r₄ = 16a₀ = 8.47 × 10⁻¹⁰ m. Ionisation needs +0.85 eV.
- 3.For 4 → 2, ΔE = −0.85 − (−3.40) = 2.55 eV. Hence λ = 1240/2.55 = 486 nm.
- 4.The atom remains bound after the emission, now more strongly than before: its remaining ionisation energy is 3.40 eV.
Problem
Hydrogen at n = 2 absorbs a photon of energy 2.55 eV and later returns to n = 1. Can it emit more total energy than the absorbed photon?
- 1.The initial energy is −3.40 eV. Absorbing 2.55 eV raises it to −0.85 eV, corresponding to n = 4.
- 2.The later total drop to n = 1 is −0.85 − (−13.6) = 12.75 eV, whether direct or through a cascade.
- 3.This exceeds 2.55 eV because the atom started excited. Accounting for the net atomic change from n = 2 to 1 gives an extra released 10.2 eV. No energy has been created.
Keep the useful model and its limits together
Bohr’s picture predicts the leading one-electron spectrum and binding energy, but it does not determine line intensities, electron–electron interactions or the exact modern state structure. A nonradiating stationary state is not static equilibrium of a resting classical charge. A modern orbital is not a corrected circle. Studying this sequence shows how a model can retain a successful part, such as a compact nucleus, while replacing a failed part, such as classical atomic radiation.
The following mixed problems require a choice of principle. Begin each solution by identifying the system, initial and final states, and assumptions. A short physical justification is more valuable than a formula chosen only because it contains the desired unknown.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
Which sequence correctly explains the atomic spectrum in the Bohr picture?
The photon energy comes from a transition between allowed states; the leading state energies determine the line positions.
A hydrogen atom changes from n = 1 to n = 2. What happens to its total and kinetic energies in the model?
E rises from −13.6 to −3.4 eV, while K falls from +13.6 to +3.4 eV.
A head-on α particle has twice the energy and approaches a heavy target with twice Z. How does d change?
d is proportional to Z/K. Doubling both leaves the ratio unchanged within the same assumptions.
Which pair can be used directly in λ = hc/ΔE?
Compatible energy units cancel and leave nm. In SI, ΔE must instead be expressed in joules.
What best describes a useful but limited atomic model?
A model is tested through its predictions and scope. Success for leading energies does not establish every part of its imagery.
Practice Problems
- Compare the Thomson and Rutherford pictures in atomic size, positive-charge distribution, mass distribution, and the force on an electron in their simplest equilibrium or orbit descriptions.
- A 6.0 MeV α particle approaches gold head-on. Calculate its turning distance and predict the result if its incident energy rises to 12.0 MeV. Use ke² = 1.440 MeV fm.
- Explain why replacing gold by solid hydrogen does not simply produce gold-like backward scattering at a smaller turning distance.
- For ground-state hydrogen, calculate K and U from E = −13.6 eV. Convert E into joules and explain the required ionisation energy.
- Calculate r, v and T for n = 1, 2 and 3 using a₀ = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m, v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s, and T₁ = 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.
- Ground-state hydrogen absorbs a photon and reaches n = 4. Calculate energy, frequency and wavelength.
- An atom has two levels separated by 2.3 eV. Find the emitted frequency and explain why their absolute energies are unnecessary.
- Initially ground-state atomic hydrogen is bombarded by 12.5 eV electrons. Find the highest level reached and the principal candidate emission wavelengths.
- Use Earth’s mass 6.0 × 10²⁴ kg, orbital speed 3.0 × 10⁴ m/s and radius 1.5 × 10¹¹ m to calculate the formal n = L/ħ and interpret it.
- An electron in the Bohr model has a wavelength equal to one fifth of its orbit circumference. Identify n, r, E and the minimum ionisation energy for hydrogen.
- A hydrogen atom at n = 3 absorbs a 2.0 eV photon in an ionisation event. Estimate the outgoing electron kinetic energy and speed, neglecting recoil.
- A proposed explanation says: “An electron emits light at its orbital frequency, all upper levels are equally spaced, and neutral helium is hydrogen with Z = 2.” Correct each statement.
Both address the same roughly 10⁻¹⁰ m overall atomic scale. Thomson spreads the positive charge and most mass through the background; Rutherford concentrates them in a tiny nucleus. Thomson’s simplest resting-electron picture uses positions with zero net force, whereas a circular nuclear-model electron has an inward net force producing acceleration. Static force balance in a simplified picture must not be confused with a complete proof of stability. Rutherford’s purely classical orbit collapses through radiation; the experiment itself supports the nuclear structure.
Key Takeaways
• Scattering supports a compact nucleus; it does not by itself solve atomic stability. • Bohr’s quantisation selects states from a classical circular-orbit calculation. • Hydrogen radius, speed, period and energy scale as n², 1/n, n³ and −1/n². • Total bound energy is negative, while excitation and ionisation inputs are positive. • Radiative transitions conserve energy through positive photon energy differences. • A cascade redistributes a fixed energy drop among photons. • Wave closure motivates a historical quantisation rule without establishing literal electron tracks. • One-electron successes must be kept separate from multielectron and modern-state limitations.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…
Previous · Lesson 6
Matter Waves and the Limits of Atomic Models
Next
End of chapter