Skip to lesson content

Lesson 7 of 7

Atoms · Lesson 7 of 7

Chapter Summary and Practice

“Connect scattering evidence, atomic models, quantised energies and spectra through an integrated reference and mixed reasoning problems.”

Learning Objectives

• Choose the appropriate model for scattering, circular motion or a radiative transition. • Connect Bohr radius, speed, energy and spectral predictions. • Check energy signs, units, assumptions and limiting behaviour. • Solve integrated atomic-physics problems and identify model limitations.

One connected argument from evidence to energy

This chapter begins with two sets of observations that a single classical picture cannot explain. Scattering says that an atom contains a compact positive nucleus, with most of its volume outside the dense nucleus. Stable matter and sharp spectral lines say that a continuously radiating classical orbit is inadequate. Bohr retained the nucleus, restricted the allowed states, and connected radiation to differences between their energies. The wave-closure argument motivates the integer condition, while modern quantum mechanics replaces the circular trajectory with a state and a probability description.

StageEvidence or principleResultBoundary
Charge arrangementAtomic neutrality and α scatteringCompact positive nucleus; electrons outside itNo direct measurement of circular electron paths
Classical mechanicsCoulomb attraction supplies centripetal forceK = −E and U = 2E for a circular orbitClassical radiation still predicts collapse
Bohr restrictionNonradiating states and L = nħDiscrete r, v and EA semiclassical one-electron model
Radiative transitionsEnergy conservation and photon energyhν equals a level differenceLine intensity needs more information
Wave descriptionPeriodic phase closureInteger wavelengths motivate quantisationAn orbital is not the circular loop

A reference that includes conditions

RelationshipMeaning and symbolsUnitsConditions and limits
F = 2kZe²/r²Repulsive α–nucleus force; r is separationN; r in m; e in COutside a compact nuclear charge distribution
d = 2kZe²/KHead-on Coulomb turning distancem when K is JHeavy fixed target; negligible energy losses; not a contact radius
mₑv²/r = ke²/r²Electric attraction supplies centripetal accelerationForce in NHydrogen; circular motion; approximately fixed proton
K = ke²/(2r); U = −ke²/r; E = −ke²/(2r)Kinetic, potential and total energiesJ in SIU zero at infinity; circular attractive Coulomb model
mₑvₙrₙ = nħAllowed Bohr angular momentumJ s or kg m²/sPositive integer n; not the exact modern angular-momentum rule
rₙ = a₀n²; a₀ = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ mAllowed hydrogen radiusmFixed-proton nonrelativistic Bohr model
vₙ = v₁/n; v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/sHydrogen orbital speedm/sSame circular model
Tₙ = 2πrₙ/vₙ = T₁n³Revolution period; T₁ ≈ 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ ssOrbital period, not photon period
Eₙ = −13.6/n² eVLeading bound-state energyeV; multiply by 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ for JHydrogen, chosen zero at the ionisation threshold
Iₙ = −EₙPositive ionisation energyeV or J consistentlyMinimum energy from the specified initial state
hν = |Ef − Ei|; λ = hc/|Ef − Ei|Photon energy, frequency and vacuum wavelengthJ, Hz, m; or hc ≈ 1240 eV nmA specified radiative transition with a positive gap
λmatter = h/p; 2πr = nλmatterMomentum wavelength and historical loop closurem; p in kg m/sCircular-wave motivation; not a complete atomic wavefunction

The same letter can occur in different contexts. In scattering, K means the incident α-particle kinetic energy. In the bound-orbit calculation, K means electron kinetic energy. In photon calculations, ν is the radiation frequency; f_rev means revolution frequency. State the physical object and process before choosing a relationship. At a numerical step, an energy in eV must be converted to joules before combining with h in J s.

The derivations form a chain

For scattering, the chain is energy conservation → zero speed in the head-on fixed-target limit → K = 2kZe²/d. For hydrogen, the chain is electric force → circular acceleration → K, U and E → angular-momentum quantisation → allowed radius → allowed energy. For spectra, the chain is initial and final atomic states → positive energy gap → hν → wavelength. Mixing these chains is a common source of errors, such as treating a turning point as a nuclear surface or inserting a revolution frequency into a photon calculation.

Key derivation chain for hydrogenLaTeX
The first relation is mechanical, the second is a Bohr postulate, and the later results are derived within that model. Quantisation is not obtained from force balance alone.
Hydrogen transitionsE (eV)Free-electron continuum-13.60n = 1-3.40n = 2n = 3: -1.511 eVn = 4: -0.850 eVn = 5: -0.544 eV03 → 21 → 4Energy positions are linear; horizontal length is arbitrary.n = ∞ labels a limit, not another bound orbit.
Energy changes on one diagram— Downward and upward arrows encode atomic energy loss and gain. The continuum is separated from the discrete bound levels.

Check a result before trusting it

A radius and a speed magnitude must be positive. A bound hydrogen total energy must be negative with this zero. A photon energy and wavelength must be positive. An excitation raises total energy, whereas emission lowers it. A higher principal level has a larger Bohr radius, smaller speed, longer revolution period and less negative total energy. These checks often reveal a sign or exponent error before detailed arithmetic does.

A graph should also obey the physical relation. Nuclear-scattering counts decrease strongly toward large deflections for a fixed acceptance, while upper bound-state energies crowd toward zero. An orbit-radius drawing and an energy-level diagram must not be read with the same scale. In a spectrum, greater photon energy means shorter wavelength, so a larger downward arrow belongs to a line farther toward the short-wavelength end.

Identifying a state from its energy

Problem
A hydrogen atom is at E = −0.85 eV. Find its Bohr radius, ionisation energy, and the wavelength for a direct transition to n = 2.

  1. 1.Use −13.6/n² = −0.85. Thus n² = 16 and the positive integer is n = 4.
  2. 2.r₄ = 16a₀ = 8.47 × 10⁻¹⁰ m. Ionisation needs +0.85 eV.
  3. 3.For 4 → 2, ΔE = −0.85 − (−3.40) = 2.55 eV. Hence λ = 1240/2.55 = 486 nm.
  4. 4.The atom remains bound after the emission, now more strongly than before: its remaining ionisation energy is 3.40 eV.
A photon pathway and energy bookkeeping

Problem
Hydrogen at n = 2 absorbs a photon of energy 2.55 eV and later returns to n = 1. Can it emit more total energy than the absorbed photon?

  1. 1.The initial energy is −3.40 eV. Absorbing 2.55 eV raises it to −0.85 eV, corresponding to n = 4.
  2. 2.The later total drop to n = 1 is −0.85 − (−13.6) = 12.75 eV, whether direct or through a cascade.
  3. 3.This exceeds 2.55 eV because the atom started excited. Accounting for the net atomic change from n = 2 to 1 gives an extra released 10.2 eV. No energy has been created.

Keep the useful model and its limits together

Bohr’s picture predicts the leading one-electron spectrum and binding energy, but it does not determine line intensities, electron–electron interactions or the exact modern state structure. A nonradiating stationary state is not static equilibrium of a resting classical charge. A modern orbital is not a corrected circle. Studying this sequence shows how a model can retain a successful part, such as a compact nucleus, while replacing a failed part, such as classical atomic radiation.

The following mixed problems require a choice of principle. Begin each solution by identifying the system, initial and final states, and assumptions. A short physical justification is more valuable than a formula chosen only because it contains the desired unknown.

Quick Quiz

Quiz

Quick check

Which sequence correctly explains the atomic spectrum in the Bohr picture?

The photon energy comes from a transition between allowed states; the leading state energies determine the line positions.

Quick check

A hydrogen atom changes from n = 1 to n = 2. What happens to its total and kinetic energies in the model?

E rises from −13.6 to −3.4 eV, while K falls from +13.6 to +3.4 eV.

Quick check

A head-on α particle has twice the energy and approaches a heavy target with twice Z. How does d change?

d is proportional to Z/K. Doubling both leaves the ratio unchanged within the same assumptions.

Quick check

Which pair can be used directly in λ = hc/ΔE?

Compatible energy units cancel and leave nm. In SI, ΔE must instead be expressed in joules.

Quick check

What best describes a useful but limited atomic model?

A model is tested through its predictions and scope. Success for leading energies does not establish every part of its imagery.

Practice Problems

Practice Problems
  1. Compare the Thomson and Rutherford pictures in atomic size, positive-charge distribution, mass distribution, and the force on an electron in their simplest equilibrium or orbit descriptions.
  2. A 6.0 MeV α particle approaches gold head-on. Calculate its turning distance and predict the result if its incident energy rises to 12.0 MeV. Use ke² = 1.440 MeV fm.
  3. Explain why replacing gold by solid hydrogen does not simply produce gold-like backward scattering at a smaller turning distance.
  4. For ground-state hydrogen, calculate K and U from E = −13.6 eV. Convert E into joules and explain the required ionisation energy.
  5. Calculate r, v and T for n = 1, 2 and 3 using a₀ = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m, v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s, and T₁ = 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.
  6. Ground-state hydrogen absorbs a photon and reaches n = 4. Calculate energy, frequency and wavelength.
  7. An atom has two levels separated by 2.3 eV. Find the emitted frequency and explain why their absolute energies are unnecessary.
  8. Initially ground-state atomic hydrogen is bombarded by 12.5 eV electrons. Find the highest level reached and the principal candidate emission wavelengths.
  9. Use Earth’s mass 6.0 × 10²⁴ kg, orbital speed 3.0 × 10⁴ m/s and radius 1.5 × 10¹¹ m to calculate the formal n = L/ħ and interpret it.
  10. An electron in the Bohr model has a wavelength equal to one fifth of its orbit circumference. Identify n, r, E and the minimum ionisation energy for hydrogen.
  11. A hydrogen atom at n = 3 absorbs a 2.0 eV photon in an ionisation event. Estimate the outgoing electron kinetic energy and speed, neglecting recoil.
  12. A proposed explanation says: “An electron emits light at its orbital frequency, all upper levels are equally spaced, and neutral helium is hydrogen with Z = 2.” Correct each statement.

Both address the same roughly 10⁻¹⁰ m overall atomic scale. Thomson spreads the positive charge and most mass through the background; Rutherford concentrates them in a tiny nucleus. Thomson’s simplest resting-electron picture uses positions with zero net force, whereas a circular nuclear-model electron has an inward net force producing acceleration. Static force balance in a simplified picture must not be confused with a complete proof of stability. Rutherford’s purely classical orbit collapses through radiation; the experiment itself supports the nuclear structure.

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

• Scattering supports a compact nucleus; it does not by itself solve atomic stability. • Bohr’s quantisation selects states from a classical circular-orbit calculation. • Hydrogen radius, speed, period and energy scale as n², 1/n, n³ and −1/n². • Total bound energy is negative, while excitation and ionisation inputs are positive. • Radiative transitions conserve energy through positive photon energy differences. • A cascade redistributes a fixed energy drop among photons. • Wave closure motivates a historical quantisation rule without establishing literal electron tracks. • One-electron successes must be kept separate from multielectron and modern-state limitations.

Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.

Loading your progress…