Atoms · Lesson 2 of 7
Coulomb Orbits and the Classical Atom
“Derive the mechanical energy of a circular electron orbit and explain why classical mechanics and radiation cannot together produce a stable atom.”
• Relate the attractive Coulomb force to centripetal acceleration. • Derive and interpret K, U and E for a circular hydrogen orbit. • Explain negative total energy using a chosen energy zero. • Distinguish mechanical force balance from radiative stability.
A moving electron can have constant speed and still accelerate
In the nuclear picture, why does an attracted electron not simply remain at rest outside the proton? A resting electron experiences an inward electric force. Classical mechanics allows circular motion if its tangential velocity and inward acceleration have the appropriate values. Even at constant speed, its velocity direction changes, so its acceleration is nonzero. Recall that centripetal force is a description of the net inward force, not a second force to add to the Coulomb attraction.
Take a hydrogen atom with one electron of mass mₑ and charge −e, and a proton of charge +e. Approximate the proton as fixed because it is much heavier. Let r denote their separation and v the electron speed. Choose the radial outward direction as positive. The Coulomb force is inward; its radial component is negative. For the circular-orbit calculation, equate magnitudes of force and required acceleration.
The relation permits continuously many r and v pairs. It tells us which speed would support a chosen circular orbit, but it does not tell us why atoms of the same element share definite energies. If r is multiplied by four, the required speed is halved. Faster circular orbits lie closer to the proton, rather than farther out.
The energy zero and the origin of the minus sign
Define electrostatic potential energy to be zero when the electron and proton are infinitely separated. Bringing opposite charges closer releases energy, so their potential energy is negative. It belongs to their interaction, although the fixed-proton approximation often calls it the electron’s potential energy. Kinetic energy is always nonnegative. Use the force relation before combining the two.
Substitution is explicit: one-half of mₑv² is one-half of ke²/r. The attractive potential energy is minus ke²/r, twice as large in magnitude as K. Therefore the sum is negative, even though the electron is moving.
A negative energy is not a negative speed, mass or amount of motion. It says the total lies below our chosen zero. Supplying −E raises the system to the threshold E = 0; any additional energy can appear as kinetic energy of separated particles. Increasing r makes E less negative, so it increases the total energy. K decreases at the same time. There is no contradiction: U rises by twice the decrease in K.
Problem
Use E = −13.6 eV, ke² = 2.307 × 10⁻²⁸ J m and mₑ = 9.109 × 10⁻³¹ kg to estimate a circular hydrogen orbit.
- 1.Convert E = −13.6 × 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ = −2.179 × 10⁻¹⁸ J. Rearrange E = −ke²/(2r) to obtain r = −ke²/(2E).
- 2.Substitute r = 2.307 × 10⁻²⁸ / (4.358 × 10⁻¹⁸) = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m. Both the explicit minus sign and the negative E are needed to give a positive radius.
- 3.K = −E = 2.179 × 10⁻¹⁸ J. Therefore v = √(2K/mₑ) = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s, about 0.0073c. This supports using nonrelativistic mechanics.
- 4.The measured binding energy was an input here; classical mechanics has not predicted which orbit the atom should occupy.
Why a mechanically possible orbit is not a stable classical atom
Classical electromagnetic theory says an accelerating charge radiates. A circular electron is accelerating, so the classical model loses mechanical energy. Since E = −ke²/(2r), making E more negative reduces r. As the electron spirals inward its speed increases. Radiation and the assumed circular mechanical motion cannot produce a permanent atomic ground state. The observed stability of ordinary atoms is therefore a serious failure of this purely classical picture.
The same picture fails to explain sharp line spectra. The orbital frequency v/(2πr) varies continuously as the orbit changes, so the radiating classical motion would not select a fixed list of spectral lines. These are separate shortcomings: concentrating positive charge explains scattering, but does not by itself explain stability or spectral discreteness. A successful model must preserve the nuclear evidence while changing the description of atomic states.
Problem
At r = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m and v = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s, calculate the revolution frequency.
- 1.One revolution covers 2πr, so f_rev = v/(2πr). The units are (m/s)/m = s⁻¹.
- 2.Substitute to obtain f_rev ≈ 6.59 × 10¹⁵ Hz, and period T = 1/f_rev ≈ 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.
- 3.An ideal classical charge on that circular orbit radiates at its revolution frequency. A real hydrogen ground state does not emit continuously at this frequency; atomic photons are tied to transitions between states.
“The electric force balances the centripetal force, so the atom is stable.” This double-counts the force description and ignores radiation. The Coulomb force supplies the required centripetal acceleration. Mechanical motion can be consistent at an instant while its energy is still lost under classical electrodynamics.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
What supplies the centripetal force in the circular hydrogen model?
Centripetal describes the net inward force. Here Coulomb attraction provides it.
If E = −3.4 eV for a circular Coulomb orbit, what is K?
The circular-orbit relation E = −K makes the kinetic energy positive, K = 3.4 eV.
With U = 0 at infinite separation, what does E < 0 indicate?
Energy must be supplied to reach the separated-particle threshold. The zero is a reference, not a ban on negative energies.
When a circular orbit radius is multiplied by four, what happens to its speed?
The circular force balance gives v proportional to r⁻¹ᐟ².
Why does the classical circular electron radiate?
Centripetal acceleration exists even at constant speed. Classical radiation therefore makes the orbit lose energy.
Practice Problems
- Derive K, U and E for a circular hydrogen orbit without treating centripetal force as an additional force.
- For E = −13.6 eV, calculate K, U and the energy needed to reach E = 0.
- A circular orbit expands from radius r to 4r. Compare its final K, U, E and required supplied energy with their initial values.
- Calculate the speed and revolution period for a circular orbit of radius 2.116 × 10⁻¹⁰ m. Use ke² = 2.307 × 10⁻²⁸ J m and mₑ = 9.109 × 10⁻³¹ kg.
- A student says an inward-spiralling classical electron must slow because it loses energy. Identify the error.
Coulomb attraction supplies the net force: ke²/r² = mₑv²/r. Multiplying by r gives mₑv² = ke²/r, hence K = ke²/(2r). With the potential zero at infinity, U = −ke²/r. Adding gives E = −ke²/(2r), so U = −2K and E = −K. The derivation assumes a fixed proton and nonrelativistic circular motion.
Key Takeaways
• Coulomb attraction supplies the centripetal acceleration; no extra centripetal interaction is added. • For a circular hydrogen orbit, v² = ke²/(mₑr). • With U = 0 at infinity, K = ke²/(2r), U = −ke²/r and E = −ke²/(2r). • Negative total energy indicates binding relative to the chosen threshold. • An increase in orbital radius raises total energy while reducing kinetic energy. • Classical radiation would make a nuclear atom collapse. • Revolution frequency is distinct from a real atomic transition frequency.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…