Atoms · Lesson 3 of 7
Bohr’s Quantised Orbits
“Introduce Bohr’s postulates, derive the allowed hydrogen radii and speeds, and calculate orbital scaling with a clear statement of model limits.”
• State Bohr’s three postulates and distinguish them from derived results. • Derive the allowed radius and speed of a hydrogen orbit. • Predict how radius, speed and revolution period vary with n. • Recognise the restricted one-electron scope of the model.
Keeping the nucleus while changing the rules
The stability of matter and the sharp wavelengths emitted by dilute atomic gases require a departure from classical expectations. Bohr retained the nuclear picture and used classical force balance inside a restricted model, but introduced new postulates. A postulate is a starting assumption whose value is judged by its consequences and evidence. Nonradiating orbits are not derived from ordinary classical electromagnetism: they explicitly replace its prediction for atomic stationary states.
| Postulate | Meaning | What it does not mean |
|---|---|---|
| Stationary states | Certain allowed atomic states persist without continuous radiation | The electron is at rest in Bohr’s orbit picture |
| Angular momentum condition | For a circular orbit, mₑvr = nħ, n = 1, 2, 3, … | Any radius is allowed if the electron moves slowly |
| Radiative transitions | A photon carries the difference between two state energies | A photon is emitted on every revolution |
The principal quantum number n labels the allowed Bohr states. Planck’s constant is h = 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴ J s, and ħ = h/(2π). Angular momentum has units kg m²/s, identical to J s. This dimensional match is consistent with a quantisation condition, but dimensional analysis alone does not prove that the condition is a law. The condition and the nonradiation rule are assumptions of this model.
The transition postulate concerns energy: emission from a higher energy Ei to a lower Ef satisfies hν = Ei − Ef > 0. Absorption reverses the energy change, hν = Ef − Ei. A stationary state keeps its energy; the atom does not spend an intermediate fraction of a revolution gradually leaking the photon energy. This postulate explains why orbital motion and light frequency must be treated separately.
Deriving the allowed radii one step at a time
Consider hydrogen, with a fixed proton, nonrelativistic electron and circular orbit. The two starting relations are mₑvₙ² = ke²/rₙ from force balance, and mₑvₙrₙ = nħ from the postulate. First solve the second relation for vₙ = nħ/(mₑrₙ). Substitute this speed into the first relation rather than imposing quantisation on radius directly.
This calculation selects a discrete subset from the continuous family of mechanically possible circular orbits. It does not prove that an electron in a real atom follows a measured circular track. The model predicts gross hydrogen energies very well; its orbit picture has limitations addressed later. At n = 1, the radius is a₀; n = 2 gives 4a₀, and n = 3 gives 9a₀. Equal increases in n do not give equal radial spacing.
Speed and period follow from the radius
Return to vₙ = nħ/(mₑrₙ). Replace rₙ by n²ħ²/(mₑke²). One factor of n, the electron mass and one factor of ħ cancel. The speed therefore decreases as n increases, despite the larger angular momentum: the radius increases more strongly than the momentum decreases.
One revolution covers 2πrₙ. Divide distance by speed to obtain the period. Because rₙ is proportional to n² and vₙ to 1/n, the period is proportional to n³. Its reciprocal, the revolution frequency, is proportional to 1/n³. These are properties of Bohr’s orbit picture, not frequencies of photons emitted continuously from a stationary atom.
Problem
Calculate the radii, speeds and periods for n = 1, 2 and 3.
- 1.Use the same model constants throughout: a₀ = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m, v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s and T₁ = 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.
- 2.For n = 1: r₁ = 5.29 × 10⁻¹¹ m, v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s and T₁ = 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.
- 3.For n = 2: r₂ = 4a₀ = 2.12 × 10⁻¹⁰ m, v₂ = 1.095 × 10⁶ m/s and T₂ = 8T₁ = 1.22 × 10⁻¹⁵ s.
- 4.For n = 3: r₃ = 9a₀ = 4.76 × 10⁻¹⁰ m, v₃ = 7.30 × 10⁵ m/s and T₃ = 27T₁ = 4.10 × 10⁻¹⁵ s.
- 5.Check one period directly using 2πr/v. The systematic scaling is a stronger check than matching isolated numbers.
Which atoms can this model describe?
A hydrogenic atom or ion contains exactly one electron around a nucleus of charge +Ze. Hydrogen has Z = 1; He⁺ has Z = 2 and one electron; Li²⁺ has Z = 3 and one electron. Neutral helium has two electrons and is not hydrogenic. In a one-electron Coulomb calculation, replacing e² by Ze² produces rₙ = a₀n²/Z and vₙ = Zv₁/n, using the fixed-nucleus approximation. These are short extensions of the hydrogen reasoning, not a licence to apply the formula to neutral multielectron atoms.
Increasing Z strengthens attraction and makes the one-electron orbit smaller at fixed n. If Z becomes sufficiently large, speeds and other corrections can invalidate the simple nonrelativistic model. Even for hydrogen, precise spectroscopy resolves structure beyond Bohr’s one-number description. Keep the model’s successes and its assumptions together.
Quick Quiz
Quiz
What does stationary mean in Bohr’s model?
A stationary Bohr state is nonradiating with a definite energy. Stationary does not mean motionless in the orbit picture.
What is r₃/r₁ for hydrogen?
The derived radius relation is rₙ = a₀n², so the ratio is 3²/1² = 9.
What is v₄/v₂ for hydrogen?
Since vₙ = v₁/n, v₄/v₂ = (1/4)/(1/2) = 1/2.
Which species is hydrogenic?
He⁺ has exactly one electron. Neutral He and Li have more than one, and H⁻ has two.
For hydrogen, what is T₃/T₁?
T = 2πr/v; combining r proportional to n² and v proportional to 1/n gives T proportional to n³.
Practice Problems
- Derive rₙ using force balance and angular-momentum quantisation. State both assumptions.
- If r₁ = 5.3 × 10⁻¹¹ m, find r₂ and r₃ and explain why 2r₁ and 3r₁ would be incorrect.
- Find the speed and period at n = 4 using v₁ = 2.19 × 10⁶ m/s and T₁ = 1.52 × 10⁻¹⁶ s.
- Compare r and v at n = 2 for H and He⁺ in the fixed-nucleus model.
- A proposed hydrogen orbit has L = 2.5ħ. Is it allowed by Bohr’s condition? Does this prove all physical angular momenta must be integer multiples of ħ?
For a nonrelativistic circular orbit around a fixed proton, mₑv² = ke²/r. Bohr postulates mₑvr = nħ, so v = nħ/(mₑr). Substitution gives n²ħ²/(mₑr²) = ke²/r. Multiply by r² and divide by ke²: rₙ = n²ħ²/(mₑke²) = a₀n². The mechanical relation alone does not discretise the radius.
Key Takeaways
• Bohr postulated nonradiating stationary states and angular-momentum quantisation. • The model uses mₑvₙrₙ = nħ with positive integer n. • For hydrogen, rₙ = a₀n² and vₙ = v₁/n. • The revolution period grows as n³. • A stationary orbit does not continuously emit a photon on each revolution. • Hydrogenic species contain exactly one electron. • Bohr’s circular orbits are a limited model rather than measured modern electron tracks.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…