Proportional Reasoning-1 · Lesson 7 of 8
Applying Proportional Reasoning
“Solve all twelve final problem types by combining ratio simplification, fair comparisons, sharing, unit conversion and interpretation of practical answers.”
• Select a method from the meaning of the quantities. • Interpret fractional answers in practical situations. • Combine conversions with sharing and proportion. • Solve changing-age and different-rate problems. • Explain and check each stage of a mixed solution.
In a mixed problem, the most important decision often comes before the calculation. Do you need to simplify a comparison, share a total, convert a unit or find how much corresponds to one unit? Different questions may contain similar-looking numbers but require different starting points. This lesson brings the earlier ideas together and gives you time to explain the choice of method, including what the final answer means in the situation.
The figures about populations, materials, farming and prices below are the supplied exercise data. Use them as stated mathematical models; they are not claims about current prices or general instructions for real-world use.
Figure it Out
Start by writing what is known and what is requested. Add units to every measured amount. Then look for the relationship that connects the quantities. A final check should cover both the arithmetic and the interpretation: a fraction of a bus may be a useful intermediate result, but it is not a bus you can hire.
Problem
Anagh combines 600 mL orange juice with 900 mL apple juice. Find orange : apple in simplest form.
- 1.1. The quantities already use the same unit, so the ratio is 600 : 900.
- 2.2. Their HCF is 300. Divide both terms by 300 to get 2 : 3.
- 3.3. The ratio describes the two ingredients, not the orange fraction of the whole. Orange would be 2/(2+3) = 2/5 of the model’s total.
Problem
Three identical full buses carry 162 people. How many such buses are needed for 204 people, and how many seats remain empty?
- 1.1. One bus has 162 ÷ 3 = 54 seats. Assume the same capacity on this trip.
- 2.2. 204 ÷ 54 = 34/9 = 3 7/9 busloads. Three buses seat only 162, so they are insufficient.
- 3.3. Hire four buses. They provide 4 × 54 = 216 seats.
- 4.4. Empty seats = 216 − 204 = 12. Round up because the whole group must fit; ordinary rounding down would leave people behind.
To compare crowding, population alone is insufficient. A larger population spread over much more land may have fewer people per square kilometre. Compare each city at the same one-square-kilometre amount of area.
The same principle appears when comparing prices per kilogram or material quantities per acre: a common comparison amount makes the relationship visible.
Problem
Use Delhi: area 1484 km² and population 30 million; Mumbai: area 550 km² and population 20 million. Compare people per km².
- 1.1. For Delhi, 30,000,000 ÷ 1484 ≈ 20,216 people per km².
- 2.2. For Mumbai, 20,000,000 ÷ 550 ≈ 36,364 people per km².
- 3.3. Mumbai is more crowded according to these supplied averages, even though its total population is smaller. The conclusion is about average population per area, not every neighbourhood.
Problem
A crane’s neck : rest of body is 4 : 6. If a person of height h had this same proportion, what would the neck length be?
- 1.1. The whole height contains 4 + 6 = 10 ratio parts.
- 2.2. The neck would be 4/10 of the total: neck length = 2h/5.
- 3.3. For a hypothetical height of 150 cm, this gives 4/10 × 150 = 60 cm. For the 155 cm crane itself it gives 62 cm.
- 4.4. Do not use 4/6 of the whole: six parts represent the rest of the body, not the total height.
Problem
If 2½ palas of saffron cost 3/7 niska, how much can be bought for 9 niskas at the same price per pala?
- 1.1. Preserve the fraction: the given cost is 3/7 niska, not 37 niskas. The weight is 5/2 palas.
- 2.2. The spending factor is 9 ÷ (3/7) = 9 × 7/3 = 21.
- 3.3. Multiply the saffron amount by 21: (5/2) × 21 = 105/2 = 52.5 palas.
- 4.4. A check is 52.5 ÷ 2.5 = 21, the same factor as the spending increase.
For an age problem, keep the age difference fixed. You may reason directly from that difference or let t represent elapsed years. Do not multiply the two current ages by the future ratio, because both people age by the same number of years.
Problem
Harmain is 1 year old and her brother is 5. How old is Harmain when her age : his age is 1 : 2?
- 1.1. Their age difference is 5 − 1 = 4 years and remains constant.
- 2.2. At ratio 1 : 2, the difference is one ratio part. Therefore one part must be four years.
- 3.3. Their ages will be 4 and 8. This occurs three years later, so Harmain’s age is 4, not 3.
- 4.4. Algebra confirms it: (1+t) : (5+t) = 1 : 2 gives 2(1+t) = 5+t, so t = 3.
Problem
For this exercise, equal volumes of gold and water have mass ratio 37 : 2, and one litre of water has mass 1 kg. Find the stated model’s mass for one litre of gold.
- 1.1. Gold : water mass = 37 : 2. The water’s two ratio parts correspond to 1 kg.
- 2.2. One part is 1/2 kg, so gold mass is 37 × 1/2 = 18.5 kg.
- 3.3. This result follows from the supplied ratio for equal volumes; it is not a general rule that all litre volumes have the same mass.
Problem
Using the exercise rate of 10 tonnes per acre, find the amount for a 200 ft by 500 ft plot.
- 1.1. Plot area = 200 × 500 = 100,000 ft².
- 2.2. Convert to acres: 100,000/43,560 ≈ 2.29568 acres.
- 3.3. Multiply by the given rate: 10 × 100,000/43,560 ≈ 22.9568 tonnes.
- 4.4. Thus the exercise estimate is about 22.96 tonnes, or 22,956.8 kg. Keep the area conversion before the rate calculation.
Problem
A tap fills a 500 mL mug in 15 seconds. How long will it take to fill a 10 L bucket at the same flow?
- 1.1. Convert 10 L to 10,000 mL.
- 2.2. The bucket contains 10,000/500 = 20 mug-volumes.
- 3.3. Time = 20 × 15 = 300 seconds = 5 minutes.
- 4.4. The model assumes constant flow and that the full capacity must be filled from empty.
Problem
Land costs ₹15,00,000 per acre. At the same price per area, what is the cost of 2400 ft²?
- 1.1. Convert the reference acre to 43,560 ft².
- 2.2. The requested fraction of an acre is 2400/43,560.
- 3.3. Cost = 1,500,000 × 2400/43,560 ≈ ₹82,644.63.
- 4.4. Rounded to the nearest rupee, this is ₹82,645. The calculation assumes a uniform price per area.
Working faster changes the time required for the same job. If one machine covers four times the area in the same time, it needs one quarter of the time for a fixed area. Explain what “four times faster” means in the exercise before choosing multiplication or division.
Problem
Oxen take six hours per acre. A tractor works at four times their area-per-hour rate. Find the time each needs for 20 acres.
- 1.1. Oxen need 20 × 6 = 120 hours.
- 2.2. For the same 20-acre job, the tractor needs one quarter as much time: 120 ÷ 4 = 30 hours.
- 3.3. Equivalently, the tractor takes 6/4 = 1.5 hours per acre, so 20 × 1.5 = 30 hours.
- 4.4. Multiplying the oxen time by four would make the faster tractor take longer, which contradicts the situation.
Problem
A coin model has total mass 7.74 g and copper : nickel = 3 : 1. Copper costs ₹906/kg and nickel ₹1341/kg. Find the material cost.
- 1.1. There are four ratio parts. Copper mass = 3/4 × 7.74 = 5.805 g; nickel mass = 1/4 × 7.74 = 1.935 g.
- 2.2. Convert grams to kilograms: copper = 0.005805 kg and nickel = 0.001935 kg.
- 3.3. Copper cost = 0.005805 × 906 = ₹5.25933. Nickel cost = 0.001935 × 1341 = ₹2.594835.
- 4.4. Add before rounding: total = ₹7.854165 ≈ ₹7.85. This is only the model’s metal cost, not manufacturing cost or monetary value.
Use HCF for simplifying a ratio; common-amount comparison for prices or crowding; total ratio parts for sharing; fixed differences for changing ages; and unit conversion before comparing mismatched measures. Practical answers may need rounding up or an explicit approximation.
Quiz
Three full buses hold 162 people. How many identical buses carry 204 people?
Which comparison measures average crowding?
Harmain is 1 and her brother is 5. When their ratio is 1 : 2, how old is Harmain?
At constant flow, how long does a tap take for 10 L if 500 mL takes 15 seconds?
What should you do before multiplying a metal’s mass in grams by a price per kilogram?
Practice Problems
- A drink contains 600 mL orange juice and 900 mL apple juice. Find the ratio and the orange fraction of the total.
- Three full 54-seat buses carried a group. This time 204 people travel. Find buses needed and unused seats.
- At the exercise rate of ten tonnes per acre, calculate the amount for a 200 ft by 500 ft plot.
- If 2½ palas cost 3/7 niska, find how many palas cost 9 niskas.
- Find the copper and nickel masses and total metal cost for the 7.74 g, 3 : 1 coin model with prices ₹906/kg and ₹1341/kg.
1. The ratio is 600 : 900 = 2 : 3. 2. The whole contains five ratio parts, so orange is 2/5 of the total.
1. 204/54 lies between three and four, so four buses are needed. 2. Their total capacity is 216; unused seats = 216 − 204 = 12.
1. Area = 100,000 ft². In acres it is 100,000/43,560. 2. Multiply by ten to obtain approximately 22.9568 tonnes, or 22.96 tonnes to two decimal places.
1. Cost factor = 9 ÷ (3/7) = 21. 2. Weight = 2½ × 21 = 52½ palas. 3. Both corresponding quantities have been multiplied by the same factor.
1. Masses: 5.805 g copper and 1.935 g nickel. 2. In kilograms these are 0.005805 and 0.001935. 3. Costs are ₹5.25933 and ₹2.594835, totalling ₹7.854165 ≈ ₹7.85. 4. Check the masses add to 7.74 g and their ratio is 3 : 1 before pricing.
Key Takeaways
• Choose a method from the quantities and relationships, not just the appearance of the numbers. • A fair comparison often uses the same unit amount, such as one kilogram or one square kilometre. • Round capacity requirements up when all people or objects must fit. • Age differences remain constant even when age ratios change. • Convert units before applying a rate or comparing ratios. • Label approximate results and explain the assumptions behind practical models.
Finished this lesson? Mark it complete to track your progress.
Loading your progress…