Tales by Dots and Lines · Lesson 5 of 13
Working Backwards from a Mean
“Recover totals, find missing observations, correct errors, and construct datasets.”
• Recover a total from a mean and a count. • Find one missing observation and correct an incorrectly recorded value. • Compare group means without averaging unequal groups blindly. • Construct datasets and grids with a target mean.
A coach knows that seven wrestlers have mean mass 56 kg, but one entry in the record is missing. The missing number does not make the problem impossible. The mean tells us the total mass that all seven entries must have together.
Working backwards turns an average into a useful constraint. First recover the total, then compare it with the information already known. We will use the same idea for missing entries, recording errors, groups of different sizes, and number puzzles.
Finding the Unknown
The equation mean = total ÷ count can be reversed by multiplication. If n values have mean m, their total is n × m. This total includes the missing observation, so subtracting the known subtotal leaves exactly the missing value.
Always check what the count refers to. If a question says seven values have a certain mean and lists six of them, the required total uses seven, not six. Then check your answer by adding all seven values and dividing by seven.
Problem
Seven wrestlers have mean mass 56 kg. Six recorded masses total 349 kg. Find the seventh mass.
- 1.The total for all seven must be 7 × 56 = 392 kg.
- 2.The six known masses contribute 349 kg.
- 3.The missing mass is 392 − 349 = 43 kg.
- 4.Check: (349 + 43) ÷ 7 = 392 ÷ 7 = 56 kg.
Problem
Eight values have mean 10.375. Seven known values total 72. Find the missing value.
- 1.Find the required total: 8 × 10.375 = 83.
- 2.Subtract the known subtotal: 83 − 72 = 11.
- 3.The missing value is 11.
- 4.Check: (72 + 11) ÷ 8 = 83 ÷ 8 = 10.375.
Correcting an Incorrect Record
A correction replaces one observation; it does not add a new observation. Therefore the count remains fixed. Start with the old total, remove the wrong entry, and insert the correct entry. If the recorded entry was 3 too large, the total must decrease by 3.
You can also calculate the change in mean directly. Divide the change in the total by the unchanged count. This shortcut is especially helpful when the original individual values are unavailable.
Problem
For 15 coconut trees, the recorded mean yield is 25.6 coconuts per tree. One count was 3 higher than the actual count. Find the corrected mean.
- 1.The recorded total is 15 × 25.6 = 384 coconuts.
- 2.The corrected total is 384 − 3 = 381.
- 3.The number of trees remains 15.
- 4.The corrected mean is 381 ÷ 15 = 25.4 coconuts per tree. The mean decreases by 3 ÷ 15 = 0.2.
Combining Unequal Groups
Suppose one group has two observations and another has eight. Taking the ordinary mean of the two group means gives the groups equal influence, even though one contains four times as many observations. To find the overall mean, combine their totals and their counts.
There is one useful shortcut when the groups have equal counts: then the mean of their two means does give the combined mean. But the count condition must be checked, rather than assumed.
Problem
Three readers have mean reading time 20 minutes, and five readers have mean 28 minutes. Find the combined mean.
- 1.The first group’s total is 3 × 20 = 60 minutes.
- 2.The second group’s total is 5 × 28 = 140 minutes.
- 3.Together the total is 200 minutes and the count is 8 readers.
- 4.The combined mean is 200 ÷ 8 = 25 minutes. Simply averaging 20 and 28 gives 24 and ignores the unequal group sizes.
Problem
A group has mean height 150.2 cm. Two people of heights 149 cm and 152 cm join. Does the mean rise or fall?
- 1.The two new heights total 301 cm, so their mean is 150.5 cm.
- 2.Their group mean is above the original 150.2 cm.
- 3.The combined mean therefore rises slightly.
- 4.An exact new mean requires the original group size. The new median cannot be determined from these means and heights alone.
Constructing Data with a Target Mean
A target mean usually allows many datasets. For four values with mean 7, the total must be 28. You could choose 4, 6, 8, 10 or 1, 7, 9, 11. Additional conditions, such as distinct values or a chosen median, narrow the possibilities.
Number grids add several total conditions at once. If each row of a three-by-three grid must have mean 10, each row must total 30. If each column and both long diagonals must also have that mean, those lines must total 30 too. Start by checking sums rather than repeatedly dividing.
| Left | Centre | Right |
|---|---|---|
| 13 | 6 | 11 |
| 8 | 10 | 12 |
| 9 | 14 | 7 |
In this grid, every row, every column, and both corner-to-corner diagonals total 30. Each line contains three numbers, so each line has mean 10. All nine entries are distinct. Adding the same amount to every cell would shift every line’s mean by that amount.
Build and Check a Dataset
Try making five positive whole numbers with mean 8 and median 7.
- The five numbers must total 40.
- Place 7 in the third position of an ordered list.
- Choose two values at most 7 and two values at least 7.
- Adjust the choices until their total is 40, then verify both conditions.
One answer is 3, 5, 7, 11, 14. The total is 40, giving mean 8, and the third value is 7. A correct mean alone does not guarantee the requested median.
A mean is not a total. Multiply by the full count before subtracting known values. When a record is corrected, keep the count fixed; when a person joins, increase it.
Quiz
Nine values have mean 12. What is their total?
Five values have mean 7. Four total 26. What is the missing value?
One of ten records was 20 too high. By how much must the mean decrease?
Can two group means always be averaged to find the combined mean?
Three cells in a row must have mean 10. What must their sum be?
Multiply mean by count: 9 × 12 = 108.
Practice Problems
- Six numbers have mean 14. Five of them total 69. Find the sixth.
- The mean of 15 values is 134. Find their sum.
- Eight weights have mean 32 kg. A value recorded as 42 kg should have been 26 kg. Correct the mean.
- Two values have mean 10 and six values have mean 18. Find the combined mean.
- Construct four distinct positive whole numbers with mean 6.5.
- Increase every entry of the displayed mean-10 grid by 2. What is each row, column, and diagonal mean now?
Step 1: The required total is 6 × 14 = 84. Step 2: The missing number is 84 − 69 = 15. Step 3: Check: (69 + 15) ÷ 6 = 14.
Key Takeaways
• Multiply mean by count to recover the total. • For one unknown, subtract the known subtotal. • Correct a mistaken value by changing the total, keeping the count fixed. • Combine group totals and counts to find an overall mean. • Check every condition when constructing a dataset or a number grid.